Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
An experiment was conducted over 2 yr to evaluate the effects of winter and summer forage type on pasture and feedlot performance and carcass traits of beef steers. British (Angus × Hereford) crossbred steers (113 steers, initial BW=249 ± 28 kg, yr 1; 98 steers, initial BW=227 ± 27 kg, yr 2) were stratified by BW and randomly assigned to graze either winter wheat (WW) or dormant native range (NR). Subsequently, steers were randomly assigned to one of five summer treatments: 1) NR, 2) ‘Jose' tall wheatgrass (TW), 3) ‘Ironmaster' old world bluestem (BLU), 4) ‘Hardie' bermudagrass in combination with alfalfa and TW (COMB), and 5) high-concentrate finishing diet. Steers that grazed summer pastures were finished on a high-concentrate diet in the fall. In yr 1, BW gain per hectare was similar for steers grazing WW and NR; in yr 2, steers grazing WW produced greater gain per hectare than NR steers (year × winter treatment, P<0.05). Average daily gain from summer grazing was greater (P<0.01) for steers that had grazed WW in yr 1, but, in yr 2, ADG from steers that had grazed WW was less (P<0.05) compared with the ADG from steers that had grazed NR. In the feedlot, previous winter grazing treatment had no effect on DMI and DMI:ADG in yr 1, but, in yr 2, steers that grazed NR in winter had less (P<0.05) finishing DMI and DMI:ADG. In yr 1, steers that were finished on a high-concentrate diet during summer had greater (P<0.05) finishing ADG, less (P<0.05) DMI:ADG, and less (P<0.05) final BW compared with steers that grazed summer pastures and were finished in the fall. In yr 2, steers finished during summer had greater (P<0.05) DMI and DMI:ADG than did steers that were finished after summer grazing, but final BW were not different. Summer pasture type did not influence finishing performance in yr 1, but differences were observed in yr 2. Wintering steers on NR or WW at a low ADG resulted in compensatory growth during the summer grazing period. However, finishing steers during summer after a low rate of winter gain resulted in less DMI:ADG in the feedlot compared with the system of summer grazing and fall finishing. If growth is not restricted in winter, compensation during grazing is not achieved, and, therefore, summer grazing is of no benefit.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Capitan et al. (2004) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: