Key result
Hip fracture surgery in nonagenarians is linked to a ~4-fold increase in postoperative mobility.
Why the study?
Hip fractures in nonagenarians require particular attention due to their age and comorbidities, and surgical treatment is often not advocated in this group in some regions such as Singapore.
Does surgical treatment improve postoperative mobility and mortality in nonagenarians with hip fractures compared to conservative management?
Cohort (n=65)
Does surgical treatment improve postoperative mobility and mortality in nonagenarians with hip fractures compared to conservative management?
Surgical treatment for hip fractures in nonagenarians significantly improves postoperative mobility compared to conservative management, without significantly increasing 1-year mortality.
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Outcomes in nonagenarians with hip fractures under conservative care remain uncertain; leaves open optimal management for this population.
To the Editor: Hip fractures are on the rise globally. With longer life expectancy, many people will reach their 90s. These nonagenarians may require particular attention because of their age and comorbidities, the former long accepted to be strongly associated with mortality.1 Unlike many parts of the world, where surgery is almost always advocated, this is often not the case for elderly Singaporeans, especially nonagenarians. The mobility, morbidity, and mortality of nonagenarians with hip fracture treated conservatively and surgically in recent years were analyzed and compared. Using a database that the authors developed,2 all nonagenarians admitted after sustaining a hip fracture (femoral neck, n = 31; intertrochanteric, n = 34) between 2010 and 2012 were included (58 female, seven male; mean age 92). The mechanism of injury was a fall in all cases. None had a pathological fracture. Six subjects were American Society of Anesthesiologists (ASA) Class 4, 45 were Class 3, 12 were Class 2, and two were Class 1. All but two had at least one comorbidity. Treatment consisted of conservative management (n = 23) or surgery (n = 42). Twenty-six of 56 (46.4%) who were ambulatory before their fracture were still ambulatory after their rehabilitation period. Sixteen (69.6%) conservatively managed subjects and 14 surgically managed subjects (33.3%) (P = .002) had deterioration in their premorbid ambulatory status. Of 23 conservatively managed subjects, 19 were mobile before their fracture but only three (15.8%) at final review. Of 42 surgically managed subjects, 37 were mobile before their fracture and 23 (62.2%) at final review. Surgical treatment significantly improved the chances of postoperative mobility (P = .002). Bipolar hemiarthroplasty also improved postoperative mobility significantly more than intramedullary nailing, dynamic hip screw, and cannulated screw fixation (P = .02). The overall incidence of morbidities during hospital admission was 41.5% (43.5% of conservative group, 40.5% of surgical group), with the most common morbidity being urinary tract infection, seen in 11 patients (five in conservative group, six in surgical group). Other morbidities included lower respiratory tract infection (three in conservative group, two in surgical group); myocardial infarction (two in conservative group, three in surgical group) one of which in the surgical group was fatal; deep venous thrombosis (DVT) (four in surgical group); nonfatal pulmonary emboli in subjects without DVT (one in conservative group, one in surgical group); cerebrovascular accident (two in conservative group, one of which was in combination with a lower respiratory tract infection and was fatal); and fast atrial fibrillation, congestive cardiac failure, syndrome of inappropriate antidiuretic hormone, and otitis (n = 1 each). ASA Class 3 or 4 was found to significantly increase morbidity (P = .04; odds ratio (OR) = 32.5, P = .01), as was having a fracture on the left side (P = .02; OR = 5.6, P = .009). Operative management was also found to significantly increase the chances of morbidity (P = .001). Multivariate analysis showed that high ASA class and pathology on the left side were significantly independent of other variables. One-year mortality was 14% (17.4% conservative group, 9.5% surgical group, P = .65) with overall mortality being 22% (17.4% conservative group, 23.8% surgical group, P = .75) at the time of review. Higher urea (P = .01) and creatinine (P = .04) levels were shown to be significantly associated with greater risk of mortality. This confirms the importance of ensuring that any elderly person planning for surgery is well hydrated and medically optimized. Even though life expectancy is on the rise globally, chronological age is often used as the reason to preclude an elderly person with hip fracture from undergoing surgery as the preferred treatment modality. Although the correlation between advanced age and mortality has been well reported,1, 3-8 this may no longer be the case. Perhaps hip fractures in nonagenarians no longer require special attention, as other authors have suggested,9 but rather demand the same treatment as their younger counterparts because surgical treatment significantly improves the chances of postoperative mobility and may be associated with lower 1-year mortality than conservative treatment. The current findings suggest that surgery, specifically bipolar hemiarthroplasty, is effective in nonagenarians with hip fracture. So is hip fracture surgery in nonagenarians really feasible? With a multidisciplinary approach and the criterion standard being involving a geriatrician perioperatively, we are the devil's advocate and believe it is.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Daruwalla et al. (2016) conducted a cohort in Hip fracture (n=65). Surgical treatment vs. Conservative management was evaluated on Postoperative mobility at final review (among those mobile before fracture) (p=0.002). Surgical treatment for hip fractures in nonagenarians improved postoperative mobility compared to conservative management, with no significant difference in 1-year mortality.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: