Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
This study addresses a long-overlooked yet important issue in body-wave travel-time tomography: whether the reference velocity model used for travel-time measurements should be consistent with the initial velocity model employed in tomographic inversion. Starting from the fundamental theory of travel-time tomography, we emphasize that observed travel-times are measured relative to a reference model, whereas model updates during inversion are performed with respect to an initial model. This nature implicitly requires intrinsic consistency between the two velocity models. We then examine common practices in current studies and analyze the potential systematic biases introduced by inconsistencies between the reference and initial models, as well as their impact on the interpretation of velocity anomalies. To further investigate this issue, we design a series of controlled numerical experiments to compare inversion results under consistent and inconsistent model conditions. The results show that when the reference and initial models are identical, both high- and low-velocity anomalies can be reliably recovered within acceptable error ranges. In contrast, when systematic differences exist between the two models, the recovered anomalies exhibit significant amplitude distortions—either amplification or suppression—and are accompanied by spurious artifacts, leading to deviations from the true model. We conclude that maintaining consistency between the reference and initial velocity models is a fundamental prerequisite for obtaining reliable tomographic images. Neglecting this requirement may introduce non-physical structures into the inversion results, thereby biasing interpretations of Earth's internal structure and geodynamic processes. This study provides a theoretical basis for model selection in tomographic workflows and offers practical guidance for improving the reliability and interpretability of seismic imaging results.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Fengxue Zhang (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: