Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Gray (1870) described the turtle species "Damonia ?crassiceps" in his Supplement to the Catalogue of Shield Reptiles, which is part of his work on the chelonian specimens in the British Museum's natural history collection (now the Natural History Museum, NHM).The inclusion of a question mark in the binomial apparently indicated some uncertainty by Gray (1870) about the generic assignment of the species.He based the description solely on iconotypes, consisting of a series of three watercolor illustrations (Fig. 1a-c).These illustrations were bequeathed to the museum in 1835 by a British amateur naturalist, Thomas Hardwicke (1756-1835), as part of a large collection of zoological artworks.Although some chelonian illustrations from the NHM Hardwicke collection are available in print (e.g., Gray 1830-1835; Webb 1980), most were never published (Sawyer 1971).The physical specimen, from which the illustrations of D. crassiceps were created, has not been located (Iverson 2022) and likely was never deposited in a museum collection.According to Gray (1870), Hardwicke acquired the three illustrations from another British amateur naturalist, John Reeves (1774-1856).While working for the East India Company in China, Reeves commissioned local artists to paint depictions of plants and animals (Fan 2004).In many instances, the artists produced multiple hand-drawn copies of each illustration.Reeves kept some of these for his personal collection and distributed the rest to other individuals and scientific institutions (Fan 2004;Datta 2018).Additional sets of Reeves' illustrations are held by the NHM Reeves Collection and the Zoological Society of London, ZSL (Sawyer 1971); both include examples of the illustration described as D. crassiceps.Based on the provenance of the illustrations received by Hardwicke, Gray (1870) designated the type locality of D. crassiceps as "China."However, the artists commissioned by Reeves often depicted captive specimens of exotic species not naturally found in China (Datta 2018), raising reasonable doubts regarding the accuracy of the reported type locality.Smith (1931) placed D. crassiceps in synonymy with Damonia subtrijuga, a species initially described as Emys subtrijuga by Schlegel & Müller (1845).However, there is no evidence that Smith ever examined the original illustrations of D. crassiceps when making his assessment.Shortly thereafter, Lindholm (1931) recognized that Damonia was a preoccupied name and proposed the nomen novum Malayemys.Subsequent authors did not question the synonymization of D. crassiceps with M. subtrijuga, until Sumontha et al. (2016) challenged this arrangement.Gray (1870) described D. crassiceps as lacking lateral head markings, which Sumontha et al. (2016) noted are present in all known species of Malayemys.However, Sumontha et al. (2016) did not suggest an alternate taxonomy (TTWG 2021), and their publication did not meet the requirements for nomenclatural validity under the International Code of Zoological Nomenclature (Thomson & Lambertz 2017).See Dawson et al. ( 2020) for an extensive review of the complex nomenclatural history of M. subtrijuga.In recent taxonomic and systematic works, three species of Malayemys were recognized, with D. crassiceps remaining a junior synonym of M. subtrijuga (TTWG 2021;Iverson 2022).Determination of the correct identity of D. crassiceps is important, as it could potentially affect future chelonian taxonomy (TTWG 2021).
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
DAWSON et al. (2025) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: