Key result
EMG biofeedback training produced significant frontalis EMG decreases during training and stress-induction, but did not produce cross-system arousal reduction.
Why the study?
Does EMG biofeedback reduce multiple system physiological arousal during training and stress-induction conditions in subjects?
RCT (n=12)
randomly assigned
Does EMG biofeedback reduce multiple system physiological arousal during training and stress-induction conditions in subjects?
EMG biofeedback training produces specific single-system arousal reduction rather than generalized cross-system arousal reduction under stress-inducing situations.
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Caution against assuming generalized arousal benefits from EMG biofeedback; leaves open its targeted utility in future trials.
The present study evaluated multiple system physiological responding which accompanied EMG biofeedback performance under two conditions—during EMG biofeedback training sessions, and during the utilization of that training in the presence of a stressor. Twelve subjects were randomly assigned to one of two groups: 1) an EMG biofeedback group, or 2) a false‐EMG biofeedback group. During the training sessions, significant frontalis EMG decreases were produced by the biofeedback group. This performance was associated with a concomitant decrease in heart rate and respiration rate, but an increase in skin conductance level. The biofeedback group was also able to maintain a low level of EMG activity during a stress‐induction procedure. However, this low level of activity did not generalize to other physiological responses. Heart rate and skin conductance levels both increased, which coincided with the subjects' self‐report of anxiety during this phase of the study. These data clearly demonstrate that single‐system arousal reduction produced by EMG biofeedback training, rather than producing cross‐system arousal reduction, produces specificity of a single response change under a stress‐inducing situation.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Gatchel et al. (1978) reported an RCT. EMG biofeedback vs. false-EMG biofeedback was evaluated on multiple system physiological responding (frontalis EMG, heart rate, respiration rate, skin conductance). EMG biofeedback training produced significant frontalis EMG decreases during training and stress-induction, but did not produce cross-system arousal reduction.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: