Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
In January of 2018, Plastic and Reconstructive Surgery launched Plastic Surgery Focus: Special Topics. This new section offers a home for topics that do not fit into the other categories, including the Continuing Medical Education and Maintenance of Certification category. Color-coded as black when browsing by subject, Plastic Surgery Focus: Special Topics articles often impact plastic surgeons beyond the scope of their subspecialties. In fact, many of the articles touch on hot topics that have popped up in news headlines. Article-level metrics measuring the social sharing and distribution of articles, such as the Altmetric Attention Score, can be observed directly on the Plastic and Reconstructive Surgery website for each article (Fig. 1). More frequently, as our field has expanded there are new topics that are of interest to our readership. Let us take a brief tour of several selected topics based off the top Plastic Surgery Focus: Special Topics articles to explore the section and review important issues covered since its inception (Table 1). Table 1. - Top 10 Articles by Altmetric Attention Score in Plastic and Reconstructive Surgery, Plastic Surgery Focus: Special Topics from 2018 to 2020 Rank Year Month Title Altmetric Attention Score 1 2018 September “The Ethical and Professional Use of Social Media in Surgery: A Systematic Review of the Literature.” 181 2 2018 January “Work-Related Musculoskeletal Injuries in Plastic Surgeons in the United States, Canada, and Norway.” 81 3 2019 March “Diversity in Plastic Surgery: Trends in Minority Representation among Applicants and Residents.” 60 4 2018 September “Factors Influencing Patient Satisfaction in Plastic Surgery: A Nationwide Analysis.” 54 5 2019 November “The Impact of Plastic Surgery Training on Family Planning and Prenatal Health.” 51 6 2019 February “Solving Congestion in the Plastic Surgery Match: A Game Theory Analysis.” 47 7 2019 May “A Primer on Social Media Use by Young Plastic Surgeons.” 44 8 2019 September “Nonbiological Microsurgery Simulators in Plastic Surgery Training: A Systematic Review.” 39 9 2019 July “Differences in Opioid Prescribing Practices among Plastic Surgery Trainees in the United States and Canada.” 37 10 2019 October “Safety of Postoperative Opioid Alternatives in Plastic Surgery: A Systematic Review.” 36 Fig. 1.: Altmetric Attention Score and social sharing of the article “Diversity in Plastic Surgery: Trends in Minority Representation among Applicants and Residents” by Parmeshwar et al. (Plast Reconstr Surg. 2019;143:940–949).SOCIAL MEDIA For better or worse, social media clearly are here to stay and have attained significant influence within medicine. Social media provide a means for physicians to network and learn from one another and have also been used by surgeons, especially plastic surgeons, for marketing and branding, educating the public, and directly communicating with their patients. Given the rapid importance of social media to one’s profession while also needing to be cognizant of patient confidentiality, Bennett and colleagues performed a systematic review of the surgical literature for recommendations on the appropriate use of social media.1 In the plastic surgery literature, the importance of consent for publication, specifically a consent form directly addressing social media posts, should be obtained and developed. Initiation of doctor-patient relationships by means of social media is discouraged, while protecting patient confidentiality and maintaining boundaries is supported. Separating professional and personal accounts, avoiding sensationalism, and monitoring one’s online presence are also advised. Most recently, the ethical analysis of posting patient videos on social media has been a hot topic, and thus the development of a consent form specific to such social media publication by the American Society of Plastic Surgeons is currently underway. For plastic surgery trainees who wish to use social media for their profession, they should be particularly selective about the content they post to avoid jeopardizing their early career from an unknowing oversight, such as the posting of patient images.2 By learning about the professional use of social media and establishing a brand, plastic surgery residents can become more familiar and comfortable with social media and with the role of social media in their professional growth. ERGONOMICS IN THE OPERATING ROOM Performing surgery involves well-known risk factors for developing musculoskeletal disorders.3 A plastic surgeon’s cervical spine takes a beating with prolonged hyperflexion and static positioning. With the head flexed 30 degrees beyond a neutral position, the cervical spine bears a 4-fold increase in weight, which translates to a relative risk of greater than 2.0 for developing neck pain.4 The use of loupes was found to increase the mean cervical load by 40 percent, resulting in more than 80 percent of surgeons who use them reporting neck symptoms.4 Headlamps, which are used by nearly 70 percent of plastic surgeons, further compound the frequency and severity of symptoms, especially when used together with loupes.4 Discrepancies in the focal length of loupes and headlamps also invite threatening postures. A combination of general and targeted fitness, such as regular exercise, shoulder raises, dumbbell flies, and shoulder shrugs, is recommended to reduce neck and shoulder pain.3,4 To protect plastic surgeons from the threat of work-related injuries, greater awareness and improved physical training are necessary to create a more healthy operative environment.3,4 DIVERSITY IN PLASTIC SURGERY Several articles in the Plastic Surgery Focus: Special Topics section have sought to investigate diversity in the plastic surgery community. Although women remain a distinct minority in plastic surgery residency programs, their numbers have been increasing over the years. The percentage of female residents in integrated programs has increased dramatically, from 26.8 percent in 2010 to 40.9 percent in 2016, while the applicant proportion has changed minimally.5 However, gender disparities are still observed with regard to authorship and leadership within plastic surgery.6,7 Furthermore, racial and ethnic gaps in plastic surgery have received less attention. Despite greater proportions of African American medical students applying to integrated programs from 2010 to 2016, the African American resident proportion has decreased.5 Aside from independent plastic surgery programs, this trend was also observed across other specialties, including general surgery, internal medicine, family medicine, and obstetrics and gynecology.5 Similarly, Hispanic representation among plastic surgery applicants and residents has failed to follow the same trajectory observed with female representation.5 With some patients choosing to forego care in the absence of a physician of the same race, ethnicity, or sex, these persistent minority representation gaps continue to deserve urgent attention. TRAINING, FAMILY PLANNING, AND PRENATAL HEALTH Like other surgical fields, the plastic surgery training environment remains a challenge when it comes to starting a family. Female trainees are more inclined to wait to have children until after training, and for those who do decide to try to have a child, plastic surgery training may have a negative impact on women’s fertility, obstetric health, and breastfeeding practices.8 Almost 20 percent of trainees required assisted reproductive technologies for a successful pregnancy, and their use significantly correlated with female sex and older age. Sleep deprivation and long work hours are associated with pregnancy complications and adverse outcomes, conceivably explaining why plastic surgery trainees report a complication rate four times that of the general population, at 56 percent. The average maternity leave taken by female trainees was 5.5 weeks, well under the recommended minimum of 12 weeks. Maternity leave that is under 9 weeks is associated with increased rates of maternal depression, anxiety, and decreased life satisfaction. Only 20 percent of plastic surgery trainees were able to breastfeed for 12 months, the length of time the American Academy of Pediatricians recommends, and the Fair Labor Standards Act of 2009 requires employers to provide reasonable time for breastfeeding or pumping until 1 year after the child’s birth. Improving conditions to facilitate starting families will lead to a happier, healthier workforce.8 THE PLASTIC SURGERY MATCH As plastic surgery has become more competitive, an applicant’s average number of published articles has increased, but is this the best metric for assessing productivity? In fact, there has been a decrease in original research articles and a greater number of review articles among the integrated residents’ peer-reviewed articles.9 The National Residency Match Program data make no distinction between journal articles, abstracts, and presentations, and “pay-to-publish” journals generally have lower thresholds for acceptance. The quality of a journal in which an applicant’s articles are published should be more heavily considered, emphasizing the importance of looking beyond the numbers.9 As plastic surgery is among the most competitive specialties in the residency match, it is not uncommon for applicants to apply to every program. This practice, however, places high financial burden and imparts significant time demands for both applicants and programs. Accordingly, setting an application limit has been proposed with supporting game theory analysis to address this issue.10 During this pandemic time especially, the application season notably in 2021 has been particularly challenging for both programs and applicants. It is clear that a virtual platform cannot supplant in-person interviews; however, virtual social hours and orientations have at least provided a means of introduction between applicants and programs. With applicants not constrained by time, travel, or cost, residency programs have seen record number of applicants across many medical and surgical specialties. In addition, research articles will be even more notable with the transition of the United States Medical Licensing Examination Step 1 to pass/fail by as early as next year and the elimination of step 2 clinical skills. We anticipate seeing colleagues writing about these upcoming changes in the Journal. OPIOIDS Addiction to prescription opioids has contributed to a 200 percent increase of overdose deaths in the United States, with an estimate of more than 33,000 deaths in 2015.11 As plastic surgeons, we inherently contributed to that statistic with our prescriptions for postoperative pain control. In addition, Canadian trainees prescribed significantly fewer opioids than U.S. trainees, indicating that the influence of adding pain as a fifth vital sign and the emphasis on patient satisfaction survey scores in U.S. hospitals likely contributed to the opioid crisis.12 Aware of our position on the forefront as clinicians, plastic surgeons have striven to optimize multimodal and multidisciplinary pain management while reducing opioid consumption by investigating potential roles of opioid alternatives in postoperative analgesia13 and reforming plastic surgery–specific enhanced recovery after surgery protocols.14–17 CONFLICT OF INTEREST According to the Open Payments database, physicians presenting at the 2017 annual conferences held by the American Society for Aesthetic Plastic Surgery and the American Society of Plastic Surgeons received payments that were significantly greater than the average payment received by plastic surgeons, indicating that biomedical companies may be influencing the content presented at conferences.18 It is important for speakers to make known the extent of their industry relationships, so that attendees of the conference may determine the possible extent of how the bias may impact the research. Having conflicts is acceptable, provided that they are disclosed. In addition, a significant discordance exists between self-reported conflict-of-interest in published scientific articles and industry-reported payments published in the Physician Payments Sunshine Act database, suggesting that some investigators may be intentionally underreporting.19 Academic status, transaction amount, and article content related to the sponsoring biomedical company are factors significantly associated with disclosure, but further investigation is warranted to explore interventions that may improve conflict-of-interest reporting. MEDICARE AND MEDICAID Medicare and Medicaid are two federally funded health insurance programs in the United States that are billed regularly by health care systems for reimbursement of patient care. However, plastic surgeons, residents, and advanced practitioners may have not received any formal training or education to understand the complexities of each program. With Congress periodically weighing changes that impact plastic surgeons, a primer on each topic by Firouzbakht et al. is a helpful guide.20,21 Nearly half of plastic surgeons report that 10 to 30 percent of their practice is made up of patients covered by Medicare. Whether Medicare reimburses for plastic surgery procedures depends on the “medical necessity” of the procedure, and clinical criteria and required documentation are strict. It is important to be aware of such requirements for proper reimbursement.20 A separate study focused specifically on evaluating trends in Medicare reimbursement in plastic surgery from 2000 to 2019, showing that the adjusted rate for all procedures decreased by an average of 0.8 percent annually.22 Although Medicare is now fee-for-service, a quality-based payment system may become available in the near future. Additional plans include transitioning to a bundled payment model of combining facility and physician fees that would be distributed as a single payment to the facility, and possibly eliminating the Medicare surtax, which would decrease funding for part A. Contributing a voice for advocacy on behalf of plastic surgeons to protect applicable CPT codes is important, as the Specialty Society Relative Value Scale Update Committee determines relative value units.20 Regarding Medicaid, reimbursement and approval for plastic surgery procedures varies by state, and just as with Medicare, the “medical necessity” of the case is important. For a plastic surgeon, knowing procedure coverage criteria for the state in which one practices is essential to serve the growing subpopulation of patients.21 CONCLUDING THOUGHTS The topics covered under the black tab, like those above, are often ones that predict and spur change. They inspire us to think, question, and search for the solution. “Are exercises sufficient to protect our necks from a career-long use of loupes and headlamps?” “How do we improve the diversity of not just our specialty, but our leadership?” “Even with honest conflict-of-interest disclosures, how much is industry influencing the content of conference presentations and scientific articles?” Plastic Surgery Focus: Special Topics offers current, exciting, and innovative articles that provoke thought, inspire research, and generate conversation (Fig. 2).Fig. 2.: The field of plastic surgery is dynamic and constantly evolving, and many new topics that are of interest to the Plastic and Reconstructive Surgery readership have arisen within the past 75 years. Although relatively new, the Special Topics section represents the Journal’s aim to expand its influence beyond the traditional scope of plastic surgery.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Furnas et al. (2021) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: