Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
In the last two decades, we have seen reports of both declining rates of drinking participation among youth and lower levels of drinking among those youth that drink. In some countries, the downward trend has been pronounced, with the prevalence of teenage drinking more than halving. Such a decline in teenage drinking is unprecedented—in both Australia and Sweden, for example, the prevalence of teenage drinking is lower than at any time since data became available (1984 in Australia 1 and 1971 in Sweden 2). These declines clearly have major implications for public health—later onset of drinking, lower levels of consumption by young people, or ongoing abstinence should lead to reductions in an array of negative outcomes both during teenage years and as these cohorts age into adulthood. Even though youth drinking has been declining for almost two decades in some places 1, 2, we know surprisingly little about the underlying mechanisms of this development. The international scope of the trends raises further questions. This special section and the 14 papers included are thus entirely devoted to declining youth drinking, and all explore this phenomenon and possible explanations for the development. We hope that this will advance and stimulate the discussion about the potential reasons for these trends. Most research on youth drinking is based on information from self-reported surveys. In this issue, Livingston et al. 3 compared estimates from surveys with more objectively defined measures based on sales. They find that surveys capture and reflect trends in per-capita consumption and that the age-specific estimates from different surveys produce similar trends, providing some reassurance that the declines reported in surveys reflect reality. A key question is whether the observed declines are occurring across subgroups of young people. Norström and Raninen 4 examined the drinking trends in groups of Swedish adolescents with various risk factors for drinking. They found that drinking had declined in all groups and that the overall decline in youth drinking was broadly similar, even among adolescents with the highest ranking of risk for drinking. Hodder et al. 5 explored the association between three measures of adolescent alcohol use and known risk and protective factors for alcohol use. They find that parallel with fewer adolescents reporting alcohol use, there has also been a reduction in the prevalence of several risk factors. Those risk factors with the strongest associations with alcohol use, including permissive attitudes towards drinking and having friends and siblings that drink, were also amongst those where the prevalence had dropped the most. The changes in youth drinking seem to have been concurrent with changes in parenting practices; six studies in this special issue identify increases in parental supervision 6-11 and parents’ attitudes towards youth drinking becoming more restrictive 6, 7, 9, 11. Larm et al. 6, however, also show changes in parenting practices of the same magnitude among those youth that drink, which implies a general increase in parental supervision that is not confined to non-drinking youth. This also limits the possible impact of these changes as the main driving factor behind the observed declines in drinking. There is some evidence that norms around youth drinking may be changing. The results by Pettigrew et al. 12 show that the alcohol is less mentioned in the most frequently played songs on radio during recent years. Meanwhile, Conroy et al. 13 demonstrate that drinkers identify several positive effects of not drinking. This could be interpreted as a low resistance in this group towards temporary abstinence, a finding that could be used by practitioners aiming to promote periods of not drinking among young people. Non-drinking may be self-reinforcing—Larm et al. 10 found that non-drinkers were better off in several aspects when compared to drinkers; they were healthier, had less mental health problems and did better in school. This special section also contains a paper by Pape et al. 14 that provides a review of the recent research literature on the decline in adolescent drinking. The review paints a complex picture and highlights the fact that few answers are found in the literature so far as to the main reason of why adolescent drinking is declining. One of the main conclusions of the review is that future research should be cross-national, as country-specific factors are unlikely to be behind the development. The authors also suggest a focus on explanatory factors at the population level rather than at the individual level. This is in line with what is suggested in the debate piece by Pennay et al. 15. In this paper, the authors outline and argue the need for a broader view with cross-cultural research to contextualise the trends in youth drinking. They also point out that most research so far has been done with repeated cross-sectional data and discuss the advantages of complementing quantitative findings with qualitative analyses. Another important note by Pennay et al. is that we might have to go beyond alcohol-specific factors in our search for the answers, as this decline in drinking is contemporary with declines in other risk behaviours among adolescents. In one of the first attempts to tackle the issue with cross-national data, Vieno et al. 16 analyse data from 24 countries to examine if there is an association between public expenditures on health and family services and rates of abstinence among 15-year olds. They find an association and potential link between more generous expenditures on health and family services and rates of abstainers. In countries with higher expenditures, the rates of abstainers were also higher; in these countries, the increase in rates of abstainers was also the most pronounced. Taken together, the results from the 14 papers published in this special issue provide a base for continued research on youth drinking. The key question of why this decline has happened remains unanswered and continues to be a challenge for our scholarly understandings of the phenomenon. In addition to answering this key question, future research need to start mapping the repercussions and importance of this unprecedented change in youth drinking, on both the individual level and societal level. However, another, more subtle, observation of this positive development raises issues for alcohol policy researchers—how do we understand the major shift in youth drinking across countries with diverse policy settings and drinking cultures? This trend is occurring across a wide variety of countries, which differ in many respects, not least in alcohol policy. Importantly, the decline in youth drinking has occurred even in contexts of policy changes within countries that would be expected to increase alcohol consumption. A noteworthy example is Finland, where alcohol taxes were decreased in 2004 and alcohol consumption in the general population increased by 10% 17 while youth drinking continued to decline 18. Finnish youth thus appear to have been ‘vaccinated’ against the impact of the tax-cuts and the increased affordability of alcohol that were enforced in 2004. That youth drinking has taken its own trajectory and does not follow trends in population drinking has also been observed in Sweden 19. That these results are not occurring as a result of alcohol policy, and sometimes even despite changes in policy in the more liberal direction, raises significant questions for alcohol policy. Understanding how the effects of alcohol policy can be mediated or even offset by broader societal shifts or differences between generations becomes critical, and might force alcohol researchers to go beyond our familiar borders in search of answers. Developing evidence and extending our understanding as to the mechanisms driving this change is critical for advising governments and policy makers how to support and maintain it. JR was funded by the Swedish Research Council for Health, Working Life and Welfare (FORTE) grant 2017-01741. ML was funded by an Australian National Health and Medical Research Council Career Development Fellowship (GNT1123840). We declare that none of the authors is in receipt of financial support or has any relationship that could entail a conflict of interest in relation to the content presented in the submitted manuscript.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Raninen et al. (2018) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: