Key result
Football refereeing is linked to marked cardiovascular strain with a mean heart rate of 154 bpm.
Why the study?
The cardiovascular strain of football referees during competition is not systematically explored or included in their cardiovascular screening programs.
Does ambulatory Holter monitoring during a match reveal significant cardiovascular strain compared to a treadmill test in football referees?
Observational (n=21)
Does ambulatory Holter monitoring during a match reveal significant cardiovascular strain compared to a treadmill test in football referees?
Football referees experience significant cardiovascular strain during matches, comparable to maximal exercise testing, highlighting the need for regular health monitoring and endurance training.
May warrant closer monitoring in active referees; leaves open effects on long-term outcomes.
Problem: As opposed to athletes, the cardiovascular strain of referees during a competition is neither systematically explored nor included in their cardiovascular screening programs. Methods: Twenty-one referees from the two upper Luxemburgish football divisions were monitored during and after a match with an ambulatory Holter electrocardiogram. The results were compared to a sports cardiological check-up including a maximal incremental test on the treadmill. Results: During the match, the referees evolved in average 17%, 32%, 34% and 17% in the “regenerative” (<80% of the HR of individual anaerobic threshold, IAT), “extensive” (80 - 87.5% IAT), “intensive” (87.6 - 102.5% IAT) and “high intensive” (>102.5% IAT) zones. During the match, the mean (154 ± 11 bpm, mean ±SD) and maximal HR (180 ± 10 bpm) were only slightly lower than at the IAT (161 ± 9 bpm) and the end of the treadmill test (183 ± 11 bpm), respectively. ECG only revealed minor arrhythmias both during Holter monitoring and ergometry on the treadmill, but a higher incidence of premature beats during the 1.5h of the match than during the 15.5h off-match period. One referee showing significant ST segment depressions during the match suffered from a sudden cardiac exercise-associated event two years later. Conclusion: Football referees experience significant cardiovascular strain. A systematic endurance training is indispensable for football referees. Regular health monitoring, including a maximal exercise test on a treadmill ergometer, should be recommended not only for athletes but also for football referees.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Urhausen et al. (2022) conducted an observational in Cardiovascular strain (n=21). Officiating a football match vs. Off-match period and treadmill exercise test was evaluated on Heart rate and arrhythmias during match vs off-match period and treadmill test. Officiating a football match caused significant cardiovascular strain, with referees reaching a mean heart rate of 154 bpm and showing more premature beats than during the off-match period.
Synapse has enriched 5 closely related papers on similar clinical questions. Consider them for comparative context: