Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
A perturbation carries a state-independent law on an observation when the same allowed transformation computes the post-intervention value from the pre-intervention readout in every initial state. The law depends jointly on the system, the observation, and the allowed value transformations. Predictive completeness and componentwise lawfulness are distinct requirements, because the decomposition into individually accessible readouts can change which perturbations carry a law even when the aggregate predictive content is unchanged. Adding a predictively redundant readout can therefore remove a law. We extend the universal boundary quotient to observations composed with allowed continuations and prove that representative-preserving transport of early boundary symbols has exactly two independent obstructions, namely loss of lawfulness and splitting of earlier identifications. The common boundary quotient acts faithfully on the future equivalence quotient, which is the coarsest state identification preserving every allowed future observation. Finite models separate this predictive state description from componentwise lawfulness. We also give a compositional certificate, two finite closure procedures, a change-of-representation theorem, and a dual closure for linear state spaces. For abelian value spaces with shifts as the allowed laws, a graded entropy defect vanishes exactly on lawful perturbations, is monotone under enlargement of the continuation family, and quantifies the difference between joint and componentwise law. The dynamics is defined by composition of operations, while physical time and a spacetime metric require further structure.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Csaba Balogh (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 8 closely related papers on similar clinical questions. Consider them for comparative context: