Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Uniform nitrogen (N) fertiliser (URNF) application is inefficient where soils vary within a field, driving avoidable economic and environmental losses. Variable-rate N fertiliser (VRNF) application can reallocate N to match this variability, but a practical framework for monitoring crop growth response to VRNF in the field is lacking. Therefore, a crop growth monitoring framework combining Sentinel-2 (S2) optical and Sentinel-1 (S1) C-band Synthetic Aperture Radar (SAR) observations was assessed to evaluate VRNF relative to the farmer’s URNF application practice in a commercial winter barley field in Catalonia (Spain). Two VRNF strategies, namely, King’s (VRNF-KS) and Robin Hood (VRNF-RHS), were evaluated against URNF practice. Spatio-temporal clustering of S2 and S1 time series was utilized to evaluate satellite sensitivity to within-field heterogeneity of soil properties identified by proximal soil sensing (PSS), while simultaneously monitoring treatment-specific (VRNF and URNF) crop growth. The two VRNF strategies produced contrasting outcomes. VRNF-RHS improved both yield (+0.21 t ha -1 ) and gross margin (+41.15 EUR ha -1 relative to URNF) while applying marginally less N, outperforming both URNF and VRNF-KS agronomically and economically. VRNF-KS prioritised input reduction, achieving an N saving but incurring a slight yield penalty (-0.20 t ha -1 ) and a gross-margin loss (-34.54 EUR ha -1 ). The yield did not differ significantly among treatments (p = 0.116), indicating that these economic differences emerged despite statistically comparable yields. Cross-consistency analysis revealed consistently low agreement (overall agreement < 34%) between satellite-derived zones and PSS-derived MZD, indicating that S2 optical and S1 SAR signals reflecting realised crop conditions rather than underlying edaphic potentials. The broadband S2 indices differentiated treatments only weakly, whereas S1 VH/VV captured treatment-associated canopy heterogeneity more distinctly, suggesting that SAR may be a more sensitive indicator of VRNF-driven within-field variability, though this reflected greater dispersion rather than a statistically significant separation within a single season. Overall, freely available Sentinel-2 optical and Sentinel-1 SAR data can complement proximal soil sensing to support operational, site-specific nitrogen management in Mediterranean cropping systems, although multi-site and multi-year validation is still needed.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Amangeldy et al. (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: