Key result
Machine learning identifies three ICU HFpEF phenotypes but shows no phenotype-specific medication survival benefit.
Why the study?
The marked clinical and pathophysiological heterogeneity of HFpEF has repeatedly undermined uniform treatment strategies, motivating identification of distinct phenotypes and medication-associated patterns.
Does early exposure to diuretics, ACEI/ARB, or beta-blockers improve 365-day mortality in ICU patients with HFpEF across different machine-learning phenotypes?
Cohort (n=4,375)
Yes
Does early exposure to diuretics, ACEI/ARB, or beta-blockers improve 365-day mortality in ICU patients with HFpEF across different machine-learning phenotypes?
Machine learning identified three distinct HFpEF phenotypes in ICU patients, but exploratory analyses did not establish significant phenotype-specific mortality benefits for early use of diuretics, ACEI/ARB, or beta-blockers.
HFpEF phenotyping in ICU patients does not yet support medication tailoring; leaves open whether phenotype-guided therapy improves outcomes in prospective trials.
Background The marked clinical and pathophysiological heterogeneity of HFpEF has repeatedly undermined uniform treatment strategies. Consequently, identifying distinct phenotypes and medication-associated patterns across phenotypes may inform future precision-medicine research. Methods In this multicohort retrospective study, patients with HFpEF were included from MIMIC-IV (derivation cohort, n = 2,511), the MIMIC-III CareVue subset (internal validation cohort, n = 1,524), and the Second Hospital of Hebei Medical University (external application cohort, n = 340). Unsupervised K-prototypes clustering was used to derive phenotypic groups, with K = 2 evaluated as a lower-resolution sensitivity solution. All phenotype-stratified medication analyses were exploratory. In the derivation and internal validation cohorts, overlap weighting was the primary weighted analysis and stabilized inverse probability of treatment weighting was a sensitivity analysis; external medication estimates were reported descriptively because adequate within-group covariate balance was not achieved. A TabPFN phenotype-assignment classifier was developed after recursive feature elimination, evaluated in internal validation against independently reclustered labels aligned by prespecified one-to-one Hungarian assignment on cluster-profile distances, and applied without refitting in the external cohort. Results The primary three-cluster solution identified clinically interpretable but partially overlapping cardiorenal-metabolic, hypertensive-pulmonary, and low-blood-pressure/arrhythmia profiles. K = 2 had a higher mean silhouette width than K = 3 (0.083 versus 0.060), whereas both solutions showed high median resampling stability (ARI, 0.940 versus 0.924). A graded 365-day mortality difference was observed across the three clusters in the derivation cohort, but between-cluster survival differences were not statistically significant in the internal validation or external application cohorts. In the derivation and internal validation cohorts, no weighted cluster-specific medication association remained statistically significant after FDR correction, and all medication-by-cluster interaction tests were nonsignificant. External medication estimates were descriptive and were not used for confirmatory inference. The fixed TabPFN classifier achieved one-versus-rest AUCs of 0.951–0.969 in internal validation (10-bin multiclass ECE = 0.028). Conclusion Routinely collected ICU data supported an exploratory framework for describing overlapping HFpEF phenotypes and reproducibly assigning machine-derived labels. The analyses did not establish phenotype-specific medication effects, and the classifier should be regarded as a research tool pending prospective multicenter validation.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Ma et al. (2026) conducted a cohort in Heart failure with preserved ejection fraction (HFpEF) (n=4,375). Early exposure to diuretics, ACEI/ARB, or beta-blockers vs. Unexposed patients was evaluated on All-cause mortality within 365 days after ICU admission. Unsupervised machine learning identified three overlapping HFpEF phenotypes in ICU patients, but exploratory analyses found no statistically significant phenotype-specific associations between early medication exposure and 365-day mortality.
Synapse has enriched 5 closely related papers on similar clinical questions. Consider them for comparative context: