Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
This summer, the Australian bushfires gripped the nation. Even before the fires were under control, the shared consciousness of the nation had shifted to a new threat; novel coronavirus was sweeping through China and South-East Asia and fears about when it would hit Australia were rife. For city-dwelling Australians, COVID-19 sent the population into a toilet paper stockpiling hysteria, and bushfires were already a dwindling memory. For rural Australia, the health impact of bushfires and COVID-19 had yet to be fully realised. Likely, there will be a substantial increase in respiratory problems associated with exposure to smoke. A sharp rise in mental disorders—depression, anxiety and post-traumatic stress disorder—can also be predicted. COVID-19 will disproportionately affect remote communities, where access to health services is challenging exacerbated by an ageing population and higher co-morbidities. Even before the summer bushfires, the river land regions of rural Australia had been experiencing the longest periods of protracted drought in living memory. In stark contrast, extreme flooding in Queensland has had a profound effect on many farming communities. It seems we are living in an era where we need to expect the unexpected, and for Australians living in rural and remote communities, the effects seem to be particularly harsh. In rural Australia, there are particular demographic and societal challenges that might explain why the population is particularly susceptible to crises. Young people tend to leave rural areas in search of better education and employment opportunities. As a consequence, the birth rate is declining, and the population is ageing.1 People living in rural communities are more likely than their city-dwelling cousins to experience multiple physical and mental health problems (multimorbidity).1 As a consequence, people have shorter lives and an increased prevalence of disease and experience barriers to accessing health services.1 The median age of death in women in 2017 was 85 in major cities and 69 in very remote communities.1 The Commonwealth Government has attempted to address these health inequalities by investing in rural educational opportunities and clinical placements as a mechanism for encouraging clinicians to come and work in these communities. There is little evidence that this has been successful at leveraging more health professionals to come and work in the bush. For example, in 2013 in South Australia, there were seven psychologists in remote Australia. This increased to nine in 2017, in comparison with 1086 psychologists in the city in 2013 which increased further to 1275 in 2017.2 The aim of this special edition is to ask questions and consider potential solutions to the complex health challenges that face rural Australians. We use the word "complex" advisedly; rural Australians will often experience both a combination of both mental and physical health problems. Environmental challenges—fire, drought, floods and novel virus—layer in additional complexity. Perhaps now is an opportune time to reflect and consider how rural communities can come together to find novel ways of working to improve their health and well-being. We think there are five key challenges that need to be addressed to transform the health and well-being of rural Australians. Health care interventions are often focused on the individual, at alleviating a particular illness symptom. Often the social community context is ignored or overlooked. For example, with older people with memory problems, there is a tremendous emphasis on getting them a timely diagnosis. For many people living with memory problems, getting a brain scan and having a definitive diagnosis make not a jot of difference to the quality of their life. What they require are communities in which they are welcome and where they are active participants. There are examples in Australia of memory cafes that are informal and social gatherings where people feel welcomed and make new friends. Walking groups and sporting clubs can also be set up to welcome people living with memory problem. Such a shift is a challenge, but one worth considering. The primary focus of health policy has been to try to get more doctors, nurses and other health professionals to work in rural Australia. Continuing to pursue this policy, to ensure rural Australians get "proper" health care perhaps needs to be challenged. There are interesting examples of alternative ways of working to meet health need. For example, robotic surgery could mean the surgeon could be located in a major hospital hundreds of kilometres away. There might be some way to go with the technology; however, a surgeon in China recently completed the world's first remote surgery using 5G technology, but on an animal and not a human. A more immediately applicable model has been reported in Sweden where firefighters were successfully trained as medical first respondents.3 In an evaluation, the firefighter model reduced the time to treatment compared to waiting for an ambulance. The use of peer workers has a long tradition in providing care to people experiencing mental health problems. Recent evidence from large clinical trials has demonstrated that peer worker-delivered self-management interventions are highly effective at preventing readmission to crisis care.4 It seems to us that there is considerable potential to train members of the rural community—farmers, teachers and homemakers—to take on a peer support role. Rather than denying people "proper" psychological treatment, it is a way of getting evidence-based treatments to the large number of people in rural communities that might benefit. We have already touched on robotic surgery; there are other ways in which technology can be used to deliver health care. Telemedicine has been operating for many years and is clearly an important part of the rural health mix. The application of artificial intelligence is an area that has perhaps not been used. Chatbots can potentially "learn" to deliver a range of health interventions; they could, for example, deliver diabetes education programs or provide tailored patient information about medication across a range of disorders. Most long-term mental health conditions develop when people are young. For example, three quarters of mental health problems start before the age of 18.5 The prevention of illness is a major focus for research and innovation. Prevention requires people to change a number of well-understood health behaviours—diet, physical activity, alcohol use—this is difficult; most behaviour change interventions are complex and not particularly effective.6 We need novel approaches to promoting health, perhaps ones that are focused on populations or communities, that engage peers in delivering interventions and embrace new technology. There is a compelling argument—and some good evidence—that local people are best placed to find solutions to the problems in their community. Empowering rural Australians to have a stronger say on how the future workforce is prepared and health services are designed and delivered is one such solution. More than any of the other suggestions we have made in this editorial, devolving funding to local communities, allowing them to make decisions about the future workforce and design of health services, has to be core to improving the health and well-being of rural Australians. Bushfires, drought, unexpected events plus demographic change place a tremendous health burden on the rural communities of Australia. The one-track health policy for the past 20 years has not addressed the obvious health disparities between the city and the country. We argue that a focus on the community, on new ways of working, leveraging technology and on prevention might be ways in which the well-being of rural Australians can be improved. Ultimately, however, it is the community, people living in the bush, that are best placed to understand the challenges they face and find the best solution.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Jones et al. (2020) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: