Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
© Author(s) (or their employer(s)) 2023. No commercial reuse. See rights and permissions. Published by BMJ. Repeatedly performing routine laboratory tests on hospitalised patients is unnecessary and harmful. It causes discomfort, iatrogenic anaemia, biological waste, disrupted sleep, financial costs and spurious results that trigger cascades of further testing and interventions. Yet, every day in hospitals around the world, patients are awoken with a predawn needle in the arm. Since at least the 1970s, medical educators have attempted various programmes to teach resident physicians to order fewer routine tests, nearly always observing that any effects quickly dissipated once the education was stopped. 3 In one memorable example, hospital administrators provided a finite number of coupons to resident physicians that could be redeemed for individual laboratory tests, quickly resulting in counterfeit coupons appearing on the wards. More recently, numerous programmes have taken a multipronged intervention approach, with some combination of education, audit and feedback, electronic health record (EHR) modifications and policy changes. These programmes are generally small, singleinstitution efforts without clear evidence of potential for sustainability nor scale. Indeed, more than a decade now since the launch of the Choosing Wisely campaign in the USA, which included recommendations to avoid repetitive routine inpatient laboratory testing, there is a lack of evidence to suggest that laboratory testing has measurably decreased in hospitals. It seems for years we have temporarily decreased laboratory testing in imperceptibly small pockets, in a cyclic and futile whackamole approach. In this issue of BMJ Quality & Safety, Ambasta and colleagues share the results of their multipronged intervention bundle to effectively and safely reduce routine laboratory testing across all four hospitals in a single geographical health zone. This was a robust effort that built upon the team’s prior pilot work on a single medical unit. The bundled intervention included asynchronous education (via an online module) and social comparison reports paired with facilitated report discussion sessions. The quality improvement (QI) approach of this programme included many exemplary components that should guide other QI study efforts. The team developed and tested the interventions on a single unit and showed efficacy prior to attempting to spread. They also applied a more rigorous evaluation plan with a cluster randomised stepwedge design, rather than merely reporting preintervention and postintervention rates as many published QI studies do. The intervention included both clinical teaching units (with resident physicians and medical students) as well as hospitalist units at each hospital. Over the course of more than 125 000 patientdays, there was a 14% overall reduction in ordering of routine tests with the intervention, and a 20% increase in routine testfree patientdays, without any concerning patient safety findings.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Christopher P. Moriates (2023) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: