Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Return has become central to migration governance, yet our understanding of the engineering of differentiated return modalities remains scarce. Existing scholarship demonstrates that return is enabled through legal and administrative exclusion. But the mechanisms by which such exclusion operates across populations in a domestic context and intersects with externalization regimes are less well understood. This paper addresses these gaps through the case of Turkey, which has the world’s second-largest refugee population and is a critical site in the European Union (EU)’s containment architecture. It asks, first, why and how Syrians and Afghans, two groups displaced by conflict and persecution, are classified and governed so differently in Turkey; and, second, how this differentiation relates to EU externalization. The paper draws on extensive document analysis and eighty-two meso- and micro-level in-depth interviews, which are analysed using an analytical model that draws on the concepts of stratification and externalization. It finds that while Syrians are governed through a temporary protection regime that coerces them towards ‘voluntary’ return, Afghans are irregularized to facilitate pushback and deportation. These divergent outcomes are shaped by EU diplomacy, programming, and financing, helping us understand return as the result of multi-scalar legal, institutional, and geopolitical migration governance. The paper thereby integrates two strands of literature that are often treated separately: research on local- and national-level stratification and differentiation in migration governance, and scholarship on transnational and geopolitical externalization and remote control.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Nefise Ela Gökalp Aras (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: