Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Organizations increasingly adopt artificial intelligence, yet most struggle to integrate it meaningfully into strategic decision-making, a phenomenon we term the “assimilation gap.” This conceptual article addresses this gap by introducing the Hybrid Intelligence Configuration Matrix (HICM), a novel theoretical framework for designing proposed human-AI collaboration in organizational decision-making. Synthesizing insights from team decision-making theory, human-AI interaction research, and organizational paradox theory, the HICM moves beyond simplistic substitution or augmentation narratives to offer a dynamic, configurational perspective. We propose a three-dimensional decision space, Cognitive Complexity, Social-Emotional Complexity, and Temporal Pressure, that generates eight distinct configuration zones, each specifying proposed human-AI role allocation. The framework introduces the Human Necessity Index (HNI), a multi-attribute preliminary diagnostic heuristic for quantifying required human involvement based on decision characteristics and ethical stakes. Further, we advance a phase-specific reconfiguration model, demonstrating how proposed collaboration shifts dynamically across problem framing, analysis, evaluation, and implementation. We also identify three inherent paradoxes, Efficiency-Empathy, Consistency-Creativity, and Scalability-Personalization, that emerge when AI is treated as a team member and must be managed rather than resolved. By bridging fragmented literatures and providing testable propositions, the HICM offers scholars a coherent foundation for future research and equips organizations with a diagnostic toolkit for architecting responsible, adaptive, and strategically valuable human-AI collaboration. However, as a conceptual framework, these proposed benefits require systematic empirical validation before definitive claims about organizational value can be made.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Affa et al. (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: