Key result
Poor exercise fitness shows no independent link to serum cholesterol after adjusting for body fat.
Why the study?
The relationship between serum cholesterol and heart rate response to exercise as an estimate of muscular work capacity was unclear.
Cross-Sectional (n=5,000)
No
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Weak unadjusted fitness-cholesterol link vanishes after fatness adjustment; leaves open independent role of exercise capacity.
A modification of the Harvard Step Test was administered to over 5000 males and females, age 10–69, in Tecumseh, Michigan. The ECG was recorded during and after the exercise. A blood sample was drawn for serum total cholesterol (Abell Method) on the same day the exercise test was given. Four skinfolds as a measure of body fatness were also taken. Heart rate response to the standardized exercise test is an estimate of capacity for muscular work. It was the purpose of this analysis to study the relationship of serum cholesterol to heart rate response to exercise. All analyses were done in age and sex-specific groups. The correlation coefficients were low and in about a third of the groups, statistically significant. This suggests that poor fitness for work (high heart rate) was related, albeit weakly, to higher serum cholesterol. However, there was a positive relationship between body fatness on the one hand and serum cholesterol and heart rate response to exercise on the other. When the effect of body fatness was eliminated there was essentially no relationship between this estimate of work capacity and serum total cholesterol.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Montoye et al. (1976) conducted a cross-sectional in General community (n=5,000). Fitness (heart rate response to exercise) and body fatness was evaluated on Relationship of serum cholesterol to heart rate response to exercise. Poor fitness (high heart rate response to exercise) had essentially no relationship with serum total cholesterol when the confounding effect of body fatness was eliminated.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: