Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
To the Editor: I commend Alexander et al. (1) for establishing the need for and great value of intraoperative cerebral angiography after the clipping of cerebral aneurysms. The authors presented two vital points: 1) some aneurysms, thought to have been closed, were shown to be left open in 10 of 107 cases; 2) some major arteries, thought to have been left patent, were nevertheless found occluded in 6 of the same 107 cases. By readjusting or replacing the clips, all of the aneurysms were successfully closed off and all of the arterial occlusions were opened. In discussing whether angiography should routinely be performed after the clipping of aneurysms, valid points were made both for and against by the authors and the three commentators. What I find especially distressing, however, is the emphasis of the need to consider "cost-effectiveness" in deciding whether to proceed with the angiograms and clip readjustments. The authors and two of the commentators, all respected neurosurgeons, considered this to be relevant. One commentator did not mention it. How far from the standard ethics of medicine (which have been in effect for 2000 years before today's bottom-line philosophy) have neurosurgeons gone to save money by failing to take corrective measures during surgery? Measures can prevent deaths from second hemorrhages and avoid paralysis caused by strokes. I think that circumstances such as these demand total exclusion of cost considerations. For any who have lingering doubts, I have a simple, although partial, solution. Do not add to the usual cost of aneurysm surgery any additional fee for angiography, even though radiological charges will be made. This should satisfy the good consciences of the authors and all commentators.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Stanley Stellar (1997) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: