Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
In Response We appreciate the comments by Salem et al1 regarding our publication entitled “Trainability of Cricoid Pressure Application: A Simulation-Based Study.”2 They correctly point out that “the anatomical larynx and trachea covered with replica skin and padding (…) do not represent the unique features of the cricoid ring.” We acknowledged in the Discussion section that “our results, like all simulation based studies, may not reflect actual practice.” We were surprised, however, by this criticism because Salem et al1 praised this laryngotracheal anatomical model placed on a force scale setting in several publications. For example, in a recent author reply letter, Salem et al1 stated “we have found that the laryngotracheal model placed on a calibrated weighing scale is very useful for training.” Salem et al1 also presented a photo of a laryngotracheal model-based simulation setting in a narrative review2 that is very similar to ours. Salem et al1 also pointed out the lack of mention about the finger position used by the participants to apply pressure on the model. We asked the participants to perform the cricoid pressure maneuver as they do in clinical practice. We acknowledge that there is no evidence-based superior finger position for applying cricoid pressure. Even Sellick3 in his initial description of the maneuver referred to different finger positions (ie, 2 or 3 fingers) to apply cricoid pressure. We also do not believe that application on the thyroid rather than on the cricoid may have biased our result. Although it is possible that different finger positions on the larynx may have different consequences on esophageal occlusion, it was not our objective to explore this hypothesis. Neither was it to train people to apply cricoid pressure on the optimal location. A third remark suggests that there was a lack of instructions and practice before assessment in our study. This was true for the baseline assessments because we wanted to capture what clinicians thought was correct without any prompts or training. Before the second phase of high-frequency training, however, all subjects were allowed 15 minutes of self-regulated practice on the scale with open access to the force plate reading. Our term “national guidelines” was also criticized because “as far as we know, there are no national guidelines for use of CP in the USA.” We agree that there are no “USA” guidelines; however, we referred to and cited the Difficult Airway Society guidelines from the United Kingdom. This national organization has over 2000 members and is the second largest anesthetic specialist society in the United Kingdom (www.das.uk.com/content/history). Anesthesia & Analgesia is the official Journal of the International Anesthesia Research Society; hence, it has a broader perspective and audience than US clinicians alone. Moreover, notwithstanding controversy over its efficacy, many clinicians still consider cricoid pressure to be a standard of care for patients at high risk for aspiration of gastric contents during induction of general anesthesia. Finally, Salem et al1 state that our conclusions seem to contradict the conclusions of previous studies.4 We respectfully disagree. The study by Meek et al4 that Salem et al1 quotes shows, as many others, that simulation-based training can improve participant skills in applying a target cricoid pressure. Our study also concluded that clinicians can improve: in our study, the odds of success were significantly higher in the first 4 cycles after self-regulated practice on the simulator than the 4 baseline cycles before any training (odds ratio, 31; confidence interval, 4.3–224; P < .001). Nevertheless, our primary objective was to assess if people could be categorized as proficient in performing the target cricoid pressure. This is different from comparing success rates before and after training. A training plan can be efficient in improving ability without allowing them to be categorized as efficient. For example, in this study by Meek et al,4 quoted by Salem et al,1 29% (39 of 135) of participants still failed the test even after education on the simulator. We believe that our study supports the notion that consistently achieving target force for cricoid pressure is challenging. We agree that an electronic sensor as described by Salem et al1 could be used in future research studies to potentially improve cricoid pressure force application. Eric Noll, MD, PhDAnesthesiology and Intensive Care DepartmentHautepierre Strasbourg University HospitalHautepierre, FranceDepartment of AnesthesiologyStony Brook UniversityStony Brook New York[email protected] Elliott Bennett-Guerrero, MDDepartment of AnesthesiologyStony Brook UniversityStony Brook, New York
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Noll et al. (2018) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: