Two public developmental transcriptomes of Hypsibius exemplaris, Levin et al. 2016's 62 single timed embryos and Yoshida et al. 2017's egg-to-adult series, have never been asked when a tardigrade transcribes its synaptic machinery: neither paper, nor two later reanalyses, mentions synapsin, synaptotagmin, VAChT, GABA or tyrosine hydroxylase. Eleven synaptic and neurotransmitter genes rise through embryogenesis in Levin's series (mean Spearman rho +0.414 against a background of −0.104; permutation p = 0.0001–0.002 across twelve parameter settings). They replicate in Yoshida's independent series (rho +0.764, all eleven rising), then fall after hatching to 0.18–0.61 of their egg-stage level. Neural patterning factors fail the same monotone test (p = 0.38–0.56), but not because they are unordered. They form a synchronised pulse: mean pairwise correlation +0.521 (p = 0.0028), all peaking within six hours, against +0.305 and twenty-six hours for the synaptic set. Patterning comes first and wiring later, and we report the failed test alongside the one that rescued it. The genes co-expressed with each set share no locus and no Pfam domain. The synaptic neighbourhood holds unannotated complexin, Shaker, synaptophysin-family and EF-hand proteins. The patterning neighbourhood is enriched for immunoglobulin-superfamily adhesion molecules (4 against 1 in 300 random proteins, P = 1.5e-6), homeodomain factors and cadherins, and includes a complete Celsr/Flamingo. Among them is BV898_05552, sister to unc-86 at 93% bootstrap: a POU4 neuronal determinant not previously reported in a tardigrade, which switches on 288-fold at about 38 hours post laying, inside the patterning pulse. Two methodological results reach beyond this question. Levin's assembly maps to only 45.5% of the 19,946 annotated nHd_3.1 loci, against 99.8% for Yoshida's, so the most finely timed dataset cannot see half the genes. And our own first time axis for Levin's series was wrong by a factor of two. The supplement's minutes are halved from the two-cell stage, and the series runs to about 101 hours. Only on the corrected axis do the programmes agree with morphological staging. Every statistic is rank-based, so no result changed; every stated hour did.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Meow-Ludo Meow-Meow (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 5 closely related papers on similar clinical questions. Consider them for comparative context: