Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
We propose the Self-Certification Amplitude (∆), a computable metric for quantifying same-source evaluation advantage in “definition–verification homologous” systems. Given two independently computable dimensions d1, d2 and an external label y, we construct a 2×2 AUC matrix aij = AUC(y, sdi ; Edj ), where Edj is the Top-N sample set selected by dj , and sdi is the scoring function of di . ∆ is defined as the diagonal mean minus the anti-diagonal mean: ∆ = (a11 + a22)/2 − (a12 + a21)/2. This paper contributes: (1) a formal definition of ∆ with an explicit external-label constraint that prevents the metric from falling into self-reference; (2) a diagnostic panel consisting of ∆, same-source mean Cdiag, cross-source mean Ccross, dimension correlation ρ, sample overlap Osample, and directional asymmetry Gasym, which replaces the naive “low ∆ = healthy” interpretation; (3) a multi-objective optimization framework that avoids degeneracy; (4) a dual-dimension collaborative learning algorithm; (5) a permutation-test calibration protocol; and (6) preliminary validation on a knowledge graph pilot where ∆ decreases from 0.377 to 0.062 while cross-source mean AUC increases from 0.539 to 0.846. We emphasize that low ∆ does not imply objectivity, and that ∆ must be reported jointly with cross-source performance, dimension correlation, and sample overlap. Full validation on public benchmarks is left as future work.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Zhang et al. (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 8 closely related papers on similar clinical questions. Consider them for comparative context: