Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Health care agencies, researchers, and practitioners have made steady progress over the past 20 years in the management of obesity in primary-care settings. The United States Preventive Services Task Force has played a critical role in these efforts. In 2003, and again in 2012 and 2018, the Task Force recommended that practitioners screen all adults for obesity and offer those affected intensive, multicomponent behavioral interventions [1]. This recommendation contributed to the historic 2011 decision by the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services (CMS) to cover the provision of intensive behavioral therapy (IBT) for obesity, consisting of diet, physical activity, and strategies for behavior change [2]. We believe that the study by J. Graham Thomas and colleagues, in this edition of Obesity [3], has the potential to strengthen the IBT benefit, as discussed after a brief review of the benefit’s current status. For eligible beneficiaries, CMS covers brief (15 minutes), weekly, individual, in-person counseling visits the first month, followed by every-other-week sessions in months 2 through 6 (i.e., 14-15 visits over 6 months). Patients who lose ≥3 kg receive seven additional monthly sessions. This visit schedule is consistent with recommendations for high-intensity lifestyle counseling [4] and is similar to that used in the first year of the Diabetes Prevention Program (DPP) [5]. CMS’s requirement that physicians, nurse practitioners, or physician assistants (i.e., primary-care providers, PCPs) deliver counseling diverges from the more commonly encountered registered dietitians (RDs), exercise specialists, or psychologists who offer this care. RDs and other professionals may provide IBT “incident to” a PCP, who must be on site when counseling is delivered. Since 2015, PCPs also have been permitted to provide IBT to groups of two to ten patients in 30-minute sessions. Three randomized controlled trials confirmed the efficacy of CMS’s IBT benefit, as delivered by various professionals who received significant training and followed adapted versions of the DPP protocol [6–8]. All three studies observed mean losses of approximately 5.5% of baseline weight at 6 months, which were well maintained at 12 to 24 months with continued monthly counseling. A fourth investigation provided more frequent counseling, as well as meal replacements, and achieved a loss of 7.3% at 6 months [9]. These trials, and numerous others (which did not offer the CMS benefit per se), clearly demonstrate that 35% to 50% of patients can achieve clinically meaningful weight loss (≥5%) in primary-care settings [5]. However, these trials do not provide solutions to the structural barriers that discourage uptake of CMS’s benefit, which is offered by <1% of eligible PCPs and received by <1% of eligible beneficiaries [10]. Barriers include lack of time, training, and financial incentive for PCPs to offer IBT themselves and similar challenges in increasing the ancillary staff and physical space needed to treat more patients [10]. Adding the 22-visit, in-person IBT benefit in already busy primary-care practices could severely limit available appointments for the vast range of acute and chronic conditions that PCPs diagnose and treat daily. Thus, most practices are not well suited for delivering the IBT obesity benefit despite the importance of health care professionals diagnosing this disease, treating its comorbidities, and educating patients about its treatment. Several actions would improve CMS’s IBT benefit, starting with permitting RDs and other health professionals to independently deliver and charge for it, as proposed in the Treat and Reduce Obesity Act (before the US Congress). Similarly, IBT could be effectively delivered by phone or video conference [4], which is more convenient to patients and which would not overwhelm the staff and physical capacity of typical office practices. This issue’s article by Thomas and colleagues [3] proposes a highly innovative model of behavioral weight management that potentially addresses several barriers encountered in primary care. Over the past decade, the authors have developed a 12-week internet-based program that includes key evidence-based components of face-toface behavioral weight management but that is fully automated so See accompanying article, pg. 1621.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Wadden et al. (2022) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: