Key result
HOMA remains widely cited for assessing insulin resistance despite failing to curb global type 2 diabetes.
Why the study?
The 1985 manuscript describing the HOMA model for measuring insulin sensitivity and secretion is the most cited paper in the history of Diabetologia, warranting an assessment of its impact across the modern eras of insulin resistance and diabetes prevention.
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Although HOMA has provided a widely adopted, convenient surrogate for estimating fasting insulin resistance and beta cell function in epidemiological research, physiological measurement alone has been insufficient to curb the modern global pandemic of obesity and type 2 diabetes without broader societal translation and prevention strategies.
The 1985 manuscript describing the HOMA model, by Matthews and colleagues, is the most cited paper in the history of Diabetologia. In this edition of 'Then and now' we assess the impact of this seminal paper by considering the contribution of this elegant work in the context of the most rapidly changing period in the history of diabetes. HOMA was born in the middle of an 'era' of insulin resistance, and was subsequently nurtured and grew during the 'eras' of insulin sensitisers and diabetes prevention. From the modern era of insulin resistance onward, researchers have sought a convenient method for measuring insulin sensitivity and secretion, and found this in HOMA. However, the explosion in the prevalence of diabetes clearly underlines that an understanding of insulin resistance and how it can be measured has been insufficient to make any impact on the growing pandemic of diabetes. Knowledge of individual physiology is important, but the dramatic impact of the modern environment may be the factor that has escaped attention until very recently. An optimist can only state that the coming 'era' in diabetes research will be a period of true translation of scientific insight and implementation of effective disease prevention.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Nolan et al. (2012) conducted a review in Type 2 diabetes and obesity. Homeostasis model assessment (HOMA) vs. Hyperinsulinaemic glucose clamp technique was evaluated. HOMA has garnered over 8,600 citations since 1985 as a convenient tool for measuring insulin resistance, though its widespread use has not halted the global pandemic of type 2 diabetes.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: