We give a principal-ideal counterexample to the arbitrary-ideal actual-link Nullstellensatz in the ordinary uncompleted complex algebra of all finite-order finite-type link invariants. With g the sum of squared pairwise linking numbers and f=g(4g-1), the nonempty common zero set is the algebraically split links, but g does not lie in the radical of fV. A character on the entire algebra is obtained by formal evaluation of the standard twist-restriction polynomial at one half. The result applies for every fixed component count m at least two and for all finite-component links; the source's separate indexed linking-number ideal in the labelled theory is not decided. This is an elementary application of older polynomiality, explicitly credited to Stanford-Trapp, Eisermann and Stoimenow. A bounded primary-source audit found no explicit equivalent earlier counterexample in the inspected bodies, without claiming historical firstness, a new polynomiality method, or guaranteed novelty. The included audit discloses uninspected final-version/body limits. The deposit includes the self-contained research note, LaTeX source and exact-rational verification materials. AI tools were used extensively in developing, drafting, auditing and adversarially checking the result. This preprint is unrefereed and has not undergone conventional human peer review.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Kriebel Alec (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 5 closely related papers on similar clinical questions. Consider them for comparative context: