Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
In this issue of SJPH we are publishing a Short Communication on the decline of smoking rates in Northern Sweden where the authors suggest that ''smoking prevalence rates are strongly and inversely correlated with prevalence of snus use, both across time and across age groups, for men and for women'' and that ''snus use may lower smoking prevalence both through a reduction in smoking initiation and by enhancing cessation'' [1].The topic is of great public health relevance and it is certainly also a matter of policy controversy, not the least since data on snus use are still rather scarce and mainly available from Scandinavia.Obviously, the epidemiological basis for causal interpretations is also meagre in view of the absence of knowledge regarding long-term health consequences.Since the inherent hypothesis is that one addictive behaviour (snus use) may prevent another addictive behaviour (smoking) and that the former is less hazardous (but supposedly more addictive), only long-term prospective data on behavioural transition coupled with health outcome data can resolve the controversy.Moreover, the obvious vested economic interests involved and the well-known global impact of smoking following the now ongoing export of this well-established risk factor to developing countries adds to the importance of this agenda.The data in the report by Stegmayr et al. are, as they rightly put it, unique in the sense that they represent a population where the prevalence of one of the behaviours is probably higher than anywhere else (snus use) and the prevalence of the other (smoking) among the lowest reported.That may indicate that a transition has taken place.Still, their design is cross-sectional, making the empirical basis for causal reasoning shaky.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
A 2005 study studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: