Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
An increasing number of stores are closing in cities’ retail areas. A retail type that has been particularly affected by store closures is the department store. Due to their size and broad assortments, many cities and retail managers are concerned that the closure of department stores as “anchor stores” in a retail area will accelerate the decline of brick-and-mortar retail by reducing retail area visits. This research studies whether the negative supply shock of the closure of a department store affects visits (measured as pedestrian footfall) to the retail area near the closed store. Analyzing closures of many stores of a German department store chain, we find that the closure of a department store reduces visits to the nearby retail area (−20.0% after 24 weeks, and on average −11.8% over the first year). However, visits partially recover over time, though to a level below before the department store closure. This effect is contingent on the (a) sociodemographic composition (larger, poorer, and older cities suffering a stronger decline in visits), (b) retail area composition (e.g., retail areas with more food and beverages and cities with a competing department store suffer a stronger decline), and (c) re-usage of the vacated department store (which mitigates the decline). Our research yields implications for city managers (e.g., the need for measures to bridge the temporary decline in visits) and other retailers in the retail area.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Erik Maier (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: