Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
FigureHIGHLY RELIABLE ORGANIZATIONS (HROs) play a critical role in healthcare due to the complexity involved in providing patient care and the potentially significant consequences if even a single failure were to occur. These organizations use systems thinking to design for safety, recognizing that safety isn't static but rather an emergent property of the system.1 HROs ensure the delivery of high-quality care, preserve public trust, and promote efficiency and effectiveness within the healthcare system. Becoming an HRO demands a concerted effort across various dimensions of organizational structure, culture, processes, and systems. There must be a strong commitment from senior leadership, as they set the tone for organizational culture, allocate resources, establish priorities, and champion initiatives aimed at improving patient safety and quality of care. This work includes identifying key individuals who understand the complexity of the organization's operational aspects and who possess the skills and competencies needed to provide vigilant oversight of organizational priorities and to drive needed change. This deference to expertise is then extended to frontline workers who are entrusted to make decisions based on their knowledge and experience, which fosters a culture of personal responsibility and accountability, opens the lines of communication at all levels of the organization, and prepares staff to anticipate the unexpected and respond effectively to unforeseen events.1 Consequently, the system learns from successes, failures, and near misses through rapid continuous quality improvement (QI) efforts. When considering opportunities to achieve strategic priorities of the HRO, senior leaders can engage Doctor of Nursing Practice (DNP)-prepared nurses to lead organizational transformation. The DNP degree preparation aims to cultivate proficient advanced practice professionals and seasoned leaders within healthcare organizations, with the overarching objective of enhancing the caliber of patient care and support for families, while simultaneously elevating the effectiveness of the healthcare delivery system as a whole.2 The educational journey for these nurses is outlined in the American Association of Colleges of Nursing (AACN) essential competencies in nursing education.3 These competencies are recognized by the National Academies of Science, Engineering, and Medicine in The Future of Nursing 2020-2030 report, which reinforces that nurses have a central role in addressing complex health system needs, including health inequities of the populations they serve.4 ACTUALIZED DNP FRAMEWORK The Actualized DNP Model is a conceptual framework that illustrates the journey of the DNP-prepared nurse and the components necessary to attain the predicted outcomes and impact by utilizing the DNP-prepared nurse in practice to achieve the goals of an HRO.2 The model has evolved to the Actualized DNP Framework (see Figure 1) with the maturation of the concepts supported by research and published scholarly works (see Table 1).5 The framework consists of three linked concepts that ultimately impact the nursing profession and the healthcare of the society it serves. The concepts include: 1) the unique skill set of the DNP-prepared nurse, reflected in the attainment of the advanced-level competencies outlined in the AACN essential competencies;3 2) traditional and innovative roles, through which the practice doctorate applies evidence-based practice (EBP) to generate new knowledge in practice and develop practice-based knowledge; 3) the value and impact that the DNP-prepared nurse brings to healthcare, society, and the nursing profession by producing quality outcomes in patient care, population health, systems, and policy. FIGURE 1:: Actualized DNP Framework TABLE 1: - Publications using the Actualized DNP Model Year Authors Title Journal Model 2016 Burson R, Moran K, Conrad D. Why hire a DNP prepared nurse? The value-added impact of the practice doctorate J Dr Nurs Pract. 9(1):153-157. 2018 Vanderkooi M, Spoelstra S, Conrad D. An enhanced Actualized DNP Model to improve DNP projects: A research brief Nurs Educ Perspect. 39(5):299-301. Framework 2024 Kesten K, Conrad D. The value and impact of practice doctorate scholarship In Moran KJ, Burson R, Conrad D, eds. The Doctor of Nursing Practice Project: A Framework for Success. 4th ed. (pp. 439-468). Jones & Bartlett Learning. 2024 Manderscheid A. The actualized DNP model: Building a roadmap for a doctoral of nursing practice faculty scholarship In Moran KJ, Burson R, Conrad D, eds. The Doctor of Nursing Practice Project: A Framework for Success. 4th ed. (pp. 456-457). Jones & Bartlett Learning. Concept Year Authors Title Journal Advanced nursing knowledge (DNP competencies) 2022 Kesten K, Moran KJ, Beebe S, et al. Drivers for seeking the DNP degree and competencies acquired as reported by nurses in practice J Am Assoc Nurse Pract. 34(1):70-78. 2023 Kesten K, Beebe S, Conrad D, et al. Alignment of DNP degree competencies with employer perspectives: The value of academic practice partnerships J Prof Nurs. 48:112-118. 2023 Kesten K, Manderscheid A, Conrad D, Corrigan C. Clinical scholarship competencies and roles to impact population health outcomes J Nurse Pract. 19(7):104663. Innovative advanced practice roles 2022 Kesten K, Moran K, Beebe S, et al. Practice scholarship engagement reported by nurses holding a Doctor of Nursing Practice degree J Am Assoc Nurse Pract. 34(2):298-309. 2024 Kesten K, Moran KJ, Beebe S, Conrad DM, Corrigan C, Manderscheid A. Leveraging Doctor of Nursing Practice scholarship to meet organizational leaders' expectations J Dr Nurs Pract. 17(2):68-76. Outcomes and impact (patient, system, population, policy) 2022 Kesten K, Moran K, Beebe S, et al. Practice scholarship satisfaction and impact as perceived by DNP-prepared nurses J Am Assoc Nurse Pract. 34(5):722-730. 2022 Kesten K, Moran KJ, Beebe S, et al. Impact of practice scholarship as perceived by nurses holding a Doctor of Nursing Practice degree J Nurs Adm. 52(2):99-105. 2024 Kesten K, Moran KJ, Beebe S, et al. Exploring the scholarly value and impact of DNP-prepared nurses through the lens of nursing leaders J Nurs Adm (In press.) Improved health delivery and outcomes ultimately inform the foundational and continued educational content needed to prepare the next generation of practice doctorate nurses in current and emerging roles to attain organizational goals. Concept 1: DNP education The Actualized DNP Framework begins with the cultivation of a distinctive skill set, forged through advanced knowledge and competency acquisition in doctoral education (see Table 2). This education equips DNP-prepared nurses to excel as experts in advanced nursing practice and leadership as they translate and apply research to enhance practice across care settings.3 Kesten and colleagues surveyed a convenience sample of DNP graduates to ascertain the competencies they achieved in their doctoral program.6 The vast majority of respondents expressed agreement, or strong agreement, regarding their acquisition of knowledge and competencies across various domains. Specifically, 98.1% of respondents reported gaining proficiency in translating research evidence into practice, whereas 97.8% felt confident in synthesizing the literature to address practice issues, and in identifying, measuring, and evaluating outcomes. Additionally, 95.4% indicated competence in designing and implementing QI initiatives, and 97.0% in designing and implementing EBP and research. Furthermore, a significant proportion of respondents acknowledged their attainment of knowledge and competencies in other critical areas, including leading interprofessional teams in scholarship (93.3%), developing and implementing healthcare policy (86.9%), disseminating outcomes of practice scholarship (94.0%), and sustaining practice change (92.9%).6 TABLE 2: - Value-added competencies of DNP-prepared nurses3,6 Competencies Examples Systems-based practice Establishes and evaluates QI initiatives Leads the development, review, and evaluation of clinical practice models to transform healthcare delivery Communicates best practices to promote translation and implementation of research findings Serves as an expert in leadership positions, committee membership, healthcare boards, and other involvement related to practice expertise in regional, national, or international arenas Quality and safety Develops unique clinical nursing programs or interventions with documented effectiveness Informatics and healthcare technologies Analyzes systemwide data to evaluate practice patterns Analyzes big data and/or conducts policy analysis Uses secondary data from the electronic health record to evaluate healthcare processes and patient outcomes, disseminating results to the external community to improve quality of care Interprofessional partnerships Provides expert review for QI projects Serves as a clinical practice specialist in partnerships that advance research, clinical improvements, policy development, and/or implementation Engages with stakeholders, including patients, coalitions, corporations, and industries to educate the workforce, develop clinical innovations, and/or conduct research and practice transformation Leads interprofessional teams to improve health and transform healthcare based on expertise Population health Evaluates and reports population health, satisfaction, and cost outcomes At the heart of both doctoral education and ongoing practice lies the integration and translation of clinical knowledge into real-world application needed for HROs. This entails a comprehensive spectrum of focus areas, encompassing heightened leadership capabilities; the ability to shape the landscape of healthcare delivery; enhanced cultural competency; adeptness in clinical practice, management, and care coordination; skilled utilization of information technology; and a commitment to interprofessional collaboration.2 Ultimately, the DNP-prepared nurse has the competencies and skills needed to harness the highest level of application, integration, and engagement to bridge the divide between research, science, and practice and drive the innovation and transformation needed to maintain HROs. Concept 2: Innovative practice roles In the past, graduate preparation at the master's level and advanced nursing practice roles have impacted and improved health delivery and access. However, the increasing complexities of HROs require expanded competencies, such as interprofessional team leadership, population health, change management, information technology, and financial acumen: the additional skill set fostered in DNP educational curricula.7 The DNP degree has often been confused with the various roles assumed by the practice doctorate in nursing. Advanced practice roles for nursing not only include advanced practice registered nurses (APRNs) (such as NPs, nurse anesthetists, nurse midwives, and clinical nurse specialists) but also include nurse executives, nurse informaticists, and policy experts, as well as other specialized roles. The 2021-2022 AACN survey of DNP schools reflected the traditional APRN programs of study, as well as tracks for administration/practice leadership.8 Specialty DNP tracks include programs in health policy, informatics, or public health/population health. With in-depth preparation to bring innovation to advanced nurse practice roles, the DNP graduate has the competencies to respond to the challenges of leading change in healthcare organizations. Regardless of role, the distinguishing characteristic of the practice doctorate is the ability to engage in practice scholarship. The AACN defines nursing scholarship as “the generation, synthesis, translation, application, and dissemination of knowledge that aims to improve health and transform health care.”9 Practice scholarship is crucial to achieve the desired outcomes of HROs. Kesten and colleagues surveyed 269 DNP-prepared nurses regarding engagement in practice scholarship in their various advanced nursing roles.10 The top activities cited included evaluating current clinical knowledge, translating current best evidence in practice, evaluating new care delivery strategies, addressing work environment issues, conducting a change in practice project, and leading healthcare teams. The authors concluded that systems change and improved quality are more likely to be realized when organizations value practice scholarship and provide the DNP-prepared nurse with opportunities to use acquired doctoral-level competencies of translating evidence to practice. Utilizing the unique skill set of DNP nurses in organizations was explored with those who hire or work with DNP-prepared nurses.11 Of the 87 organizational leaders surveyed, more than half reported that scholarship competencies were integrated into job descriptions; however, almost half reported that no time for scholarship activities was provided. The highest impact of the DNP-prepared nurse was on the quality of care, and the greatest value reported was the implementation of EBP and QI initiatives, innovative roles, and change agents. The authors concluded that organizational support for DNP-prepared nurses to engage in practice scholarship can maximize the value and impact on healthcare systems and health outcomes. Furthermore, academic-practice partnerships can be utilized to aid DNP-prepared nurses seeking support in participating in practice scholarship, thus enhancing and expediting practice transformation in HROs. Concept 3: Outcomes and impact DNP-prepared nurses individually demonstrate outcomes within health systems in their practice.12 However, although the practice doctorate has been held to the importance of achieving outcomes that impact health systems, populations, and patients, it has been difficult to accurately measure the achievements aggregately.8,13 Barriers include a lack of data collection mechanisms, as well as differences in DNP graduates' prior clinical experience and variability among the roles that DNPs fill, which preclude direct comparison.13 Recommendations include a consensus-building process to determine DNP-sensitive data points. Auto-population of data, including clinical, human resource, and billing data that occur within and across institutions, will be required.13 LIMITED USE AND IMPACT Several factors contribute to the limited use and impact of DNP-prepared nurses. For example, even though within many organizations there exists a pool of highly qualified DNP-prepared nurses who possess the necessary skills and competencies to drive practice transformation, historically healthcare organizations have relied on external consultants to address practice challenges. DNP-prepared nurses in the organization represent a rich source of untapped talent who are already immersed in clinical practice and understand the challenges the organization faces. Leveraging the expertise and insights of DNP-prepared nurses not only fosters a sense of ownership and commitment but can also lead to more sustainable and tailored solutions that are developed to address the specific needs of the organization. Moreover, intentionally partnering this practice expert with an administrative leader to overcome obstacles will help advance this work. Thus, HROs can benefit significantly from tapping into the wealth of knowledge and expertise within their own ranks rather than relying on external consultants. Another factor that contributes to the overall impact of the DNP-prepared nurses may relate to the qualities or characteristics that each DNP-prepared nurse brings to their education, as well as their previous experiences. These differences may result in a variable level of ability, particularly for new graduates. For example, certain DNP-prepared nurses may not undergo significant transformation despite their education, which may result in outcomes that fall short of expectations. The underlying reasons for this shortfall may be related to challenges rooted in innate traits, such as a predisposition toward following rather than leading. It's also possible that this shortcoming stems from a lack of confidence in their abilities or their natural propensity to be conflict adverse, which leads them down the path of least resistance. Delving deeper into these potential factors is crucial for understanding why some DNP-prepared nurses may not fully leverage their education to drive meaningful change in practice. By recognizing these underlying factors, it becomes possible to provide targeted support and resources that empower these nurses to lead projects that are designed to be disruptive, challenge the status quo, and achieve the desired outcomes, and allow these DNP-prepared nurses to fulfill their potential. Nevertheless, healthcare organizations that hire DNP-prepared nurses have identified numerous returns on investment across a variety of practice areas. For example, DNP-prepared nurses in leadership roles influence policy decisions and drive systemic changes. These nurses are also adept at optimizing healthcare delivery systems and processes that lead to efficient care coordination or streamlining workflow for efficiency. Moreover, they're well equipped to lead interdisciplinary teams and foster collaboration among the healthcare team. This leadership enhances continuity of care and can improve the patient's experience. When DNP-prepared nurses lead initiatives focusing on quality care and safety through implementation of evidence-based strategies and innovative care models, there's a potential for fewer hospital readmissions, fewer medication errors, more efficient resource utilization, and overall improved patient outcomes. Hiring and utilizing DNP-prepared nurses brings the potential for multifaceted benefits to healthcare organizations, which underscore the value of investing in these highly trained nursing professionals within healthcare settings. See Table 3 for examples of DNP nurse-led QI initiatives and the subsequent return on investment (ROI). TABLE 3: - DNP nurse-led quality improvement initiatives in a Midwest healthcare system Project Theoretical framework Patient experience Population health Cost Work life Virtual Connected Care™ (virtual nursing support) Watson's Theory of Human Caring; Donabedian Model Improved staff responsiveness; improved understanding of aftercare instructions (HCAHPS [Hospital Consumer Assessment of Healthcare Providers and Systems] measures) Decreased injurious falls and pressure injuries; attained 100% adherence to Center of Excellence stroke and spine measures Up to an 8% reduction in unit labor cost per day compared with the prepandemic period Favorable perceptions of colleague and patient safety; reduction in RN demand (hours per patient day) and turnover; increased support for early-career RN; alternative career path for tenured RN Robotic retrieval and delivery system Model Favorable staff as by and improved measures delivery of and when is within of is realized in to the clinical team that were to patient care Virtual for who have Model for in a and patient and unit to at with no safety the 3 the to support for of on unit the value of current and DNP-prepared nurses in an organization to achieve the goals of HROs a to from various stakeholders, in academic-practice include and DNP-prepared graduates. initiatives to maximize DNP-prepared potential impact within healthcare for include identifying staff within the organization with leadership potential and partnering with for education with projects on organizational goals. For initiatives may include practice leader on to ensure a practice experience. DNP-prepared graduates to demonstrate the value-added competencies of DNP education in advanced nursing roles. initiatives for all can be in Table TABLE - to to maximize DNP-prepared potential in organizations initiatives current nursing staff with leadership and advanced practice advanced education with for organizational with for education with projects on organizational goals. current and potential roles for DNP-prepared nurses to and practice scholarship in and innovative roles. the on to measure DNP outcomes within the organization. opportunities for DNP-prepared nurses with organizational experts, particularly with research, and financial to maximize organizational outcomes. cultivate academic-practice partnerships to on the and opportunities to improve education and practice. financial into graduate programs reflected in outcomes. with organizations to develop and DNP-sensitive into graduate outcomes. practice from the interdisciplinary of from organizations regarding AACN essential competencies attained by to to meet practice and a academic-practice experience that each needs as a leader and ability to change. DNP-prepared graduates and demonstrate the value-added competencies of DNP education in advanced nursing roles, using and in the organizational for QI for time in advanced roles to attain highly organizational goals. by and the on work. and outcomes. for job that include time for practice that to the organization. colleagues to with work not proficient example, research, and nursing leadership as a prepared nurse, for policy for of practice example, to the of for innovation in healthcare, and nursing identified in the Actualized DNP Framework the DNP-prepared nurse the knowledge, and expertise to support and policy be an leader in the clinical the essential competencies must be and to develop proficiency and ensure that they're into practice. are needed to intentionally the practice scholarship outcomes and impact of the DNP-prepared nurse on society and the nursing DNP-prepared nurses with leaders across all lies in the translation of research evidence to practice. It's DNP-prepared nurses to not only educate healthcare leaders on their unique skill but also to opportunities to intentionally demonstrate these essential Practice scholarship is this may occur. promote practice scholarship, an needs to be to the unique skill set to the DNP-prepared within the organization and/or through academic-practice partnerships are not only key to proficient skills but also the work with organizational strategic aims and Practice scholarship a identifying leading interprofessional and other leading and implementing data, and disseminating Ultimately, practice scholarship becomes the which HROs are
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Moran et al. (2025) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: