Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Praying in sandals is a practice of the Prophet ﷺ reported in the canonical collections, permitted by every school of law, and described as better (أفضل) in the Hanafi school's relied-upon text, al-Durr al-Mukhtar. It is also a practice that almost no Muslim performs in a mosque today. This paper asks why, and finds the answer in the sources themselves: the practice depends on the floor. The floor of the Prophet's ﷺ mosque was earth and pebbles with a small palm-leaf mat kept for prostration; the earth, by the Sunnah's own rule, purifies a sole that has trodden on filth; and the Hanafi jurists, when they suspended the practice, gave the changed floor as their reason. Ibn Abidin wrote that the ruling stands "but if one fears soiling the mosque's furnishings, one should not, even if they are pure; the Prophet's mosque was floored with pebbles in his time, unlike in our time". The paper sets this sentence beside the Hanafi rule for purifying a soiled sandal, which expressly excludes cloth and the carpet, and beside the history of mosque carpeting, which is recent. It concludes that a mosque's floor is a condition of which Sunnahs the mosque can host: an earth or pebble floor keeps both prayer in sandals and prayer barefoot practicable, a carpet keeps only one, and the choice between them is open to whoever builds. The paper does not rank floors, does not call carpet unlawful, and does not ask anyone to pray in shoes on a carpet; it concedes the force of the objection from modern street filth and presents the Shafi'i view, that prayer in sandals is a concession rather than a recommended act, in full. Its proposal is modest: that a new mosque keep an earth or pebble area beside its carpeted hall. A companion to the Sabbath Pond Test series. Web edition and source register: https://irshados.com/ebooks/form-follows-floor/
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Muhammad Kashif Irshad (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 8 closely related papers on similar clinical questions. Consider them for comparative context: