Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
I build an all-India annual rainfall series for 1901–2025 from the IMD 0.25-degree gridded daily data (4,964 land cells, area-weighted) and relate it to the growth of India's agriculture, forestry and fishing value added in constant prices (World Bank WDI, 1961–2025). Three propositions organise the analysis. First, if rain moves the level of output only for one year, the coefficients on this year's and last year's rain must sum to zero; their ratio measures how much of a rain shock persists. Second, with serially uncorrelated rain, the share of growth variance due to rain is (b0² + b1²)σr²/σg². Third, if deficits hurt more than surpluses help, rainfall volatility alone lowers mean growth by (β− − β+)σ/√(2π). Each percentage point of rainfall above or below the 1961–2010 mean moves farm growth by 0.355 points in the same year (HAC s.e. 0.068) and by −0.234 points the next year (0.049); rain explains 47.9% of the variance of growth. The two coefficients sum to 0.121 (p 0.0733), so about a third of a rain shock persists. Deficits matter more than surpluses: the deficit slope is 0.616 against 0.106 for surpluses (p 0.017 for equality), which implies a mean growth cost of 1.764 points a year. Sensitivity has fallen: the same-year coefficient was 0.418 in 1961–1990, 0.252 in 1991–2025 and 0.190 in 2005–2025, and the standard deviation of growth fell from 6.89 to 2.60 points, although a formal test of a break in 1991 does not reject equality at 5% (p 0.1051).
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Manoj Kumar Aguru (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 8 closely related papers on similar clinical questions. Consider them for comparative context: