Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
A preferred anchor in a transformed frequency distribution need not identify the process that generated its peaks. We examine a golden-ratio enrichment detector motivated by a published EEG study using analytic calculations and synthetic spectra. Independent frequencies drawn within the stated search windows reproduce small errors in mean frequency ratios without event-level coordination. In a separate spectrum experiment, ordinary alpha and beta peaks with no planted golden-ratio lattice select anchors of 7.6153 and 7.6920 Hz in two noise regimes. The full predicted rank ordering occurs in the ordinary-rhythm world in one regime and in an aperiodic-only world in another. A complete retrospective replay covers 4,600 synthetic sessions and 36,800 attempted channel spectra; independent scoring reproduces enrichment, anchor choices and alpha-frequency slopes. The slope of the selected anchor against population alpha frequency is approximately 0.653 for ordinary rhythms, 0.650 with device nuisance and -0.00356 for a planted fixed-anchor lattice. These are finite-model counterexamples to detector specificity. They are not a reanalysis of participant EEG, a test of natural Schumann coupling or validation of a replacement human-data test. Failed fits, an initial implementation failure and an unresolved protocol chronology are disclosed. Ordinary spectra reproduce a Schumann-range anchor and a high enrichment ordering in the registered detector. The audit therefore demonstrates detector non-identifiability within these synthetic worlds. It does not refute the full target human or companion-cohort studies. This is an author preprint and has not been peer reviewed. The supplement preserves nulls, adverse checks and the stated scope.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
andrei ursachi (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 8 closely related papers on similar clinical questions. Consider them for comparative context: