Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Deep learning rainfall-runoff models have shown the ability to reproduce the observed hydrograph exceeding the performance of physics-based models, but their reliability outside the training distribution is still an open question. Most robustness evaluation have focused on a single architecture (LSTM), and have used controlled forcing perturbations (temperature offset or precipitation scaling) to probe the non-stationarity condition. In this study, we evaluate the robustness of five deep learning architectures (LSTM, minLSTM, minGRU, MLP-Mixer, Transformer) against a re-calibrated physics-based benchmark (SAC-SMA + Snow-17) across 554 CAMELS catchments, driven by a six-Global Change Model (GCM), four-Shared Socioeconomic Pathway (SSP) NEX-GDDP-CMIP6 and three-future periods ensemble. The results show that the deep learning models outperform the physics-based benchmark in terms of accuracy, but their robustness is limited under non-stationary conditions. The LSTM and minGRU architectures show the best performance among the deep learning models, while the MLP-Mixer and minLSTM architectures show the worst performance. We found that the predictive skill does not imply robustness: the LSTM, the most accurate architecture, is the least robust. Transformer, the most robust on annual volumes, fails to reproduce the intra-annual redistribution of streamflow, diverging from the physics-based benchmark in both directions, compensating that difference at annual basis. Architecture, not GCMs, SSPs nor period, is the dominant factor of divergence (45 % of the evaluated catchments). The results highlight the need for a more comprehensive evaluation of deep learning models under non-stationary conditions, and the importance of considering both accuracy and robustness in model selection.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Araya et al. (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 8 closely related papers on similar clinical questions. Consider them for comparative context: