Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Object. This structured integrative review examines how digitally captured information becomes feedback in piano and adjacent music practice, and how that feedback relates to self-regulated learning (SRL) — with particular attention to a distinction that is easy to blur: observable practice traces are not the same thing as stronger claims about learning. Methods & methodology. Four OpenAlex searches through 15 August 2026 yielded 327 records and 322 unique records. All unique records received title-and-abstract screening; 33 direct-scope metadata candidates were identified, and nine reconciled evidence units met a five-condition claim-level gate covering publication identity, population and task, intervention or exposure, outcomes, and limitations stated with maximum defensible wording. The synthesis was qualitative, because designs, measures, exposures, and outcome families were too heterogeneous for a defensible pooled estimate. Scientific novelty. M-SRL is proposed as an unvalidated seven-dimension, music-specific evidence-reporting framework. It does not claim first-in-field status for technology-supported SRL or digital feedback; its search-bounded contribution is narrower — to align capture, inference, output, timing, agency, outcome, and artistic-pedagogical authority in one reporting vocabulary. Results. Evidence was heterogeneous. Favourable findings for self-evaluation, metacognition, motivation, usability, or immediate performance coexisted with null findings, small samples, bundled interventions, short exposures, and divergent measures. No general superiority of visual, auditory, haptic, immersive, or AI-mediated feedback could be established from the reconciled evidence. Digital traces increase observability; they do not, by themselves, establish pedagogical effectiveness. Conclusions. M-SRL separates observable traces from stronger pedagogical and artistic claims and offers a testable reporting vocabulary for future digital music-practice research, while preserving the role of teacher, learner, and artistic judgement.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Davi Emerick (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: