Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Relevance . The article is devoted to the study of the so-called neighbor rights, the relevance of the theoretical understanding of the legal nature of which is due to both the unresolved nature of this issue in civil law doctrine and the social significance of neighbor relations, as well as the enormous number of legal disputes between neighbors. The purpose of this study development of the most effective mechanism for legal regulation of the interaction between neighboring entities, based on the distinction between subjective civil rights and civil legal relations into regulatory and protective ones. Objectives of the study: to reveal the essence of existing approaches to understanding regulatory and protective subjective rights; to identify trends in the legislative consolidation of neighborly rights. Methodology . The article is based on a complex of general scientific (logical, systemic) and private scientific (formal-legal, comparative-legal) approaches for analyzing civil law phenomena. Results . The essence of neighborly rights is most fully reflected in the protective model of regulatory regulation of neighborly relations, which is based on the provisions of Roman private law regarding the regulation of neighborly relations, which were essentially a system of subjective protective rights. The thesis is put forward that it is more accurate to speak not about subjective neighbor rights, but about neighbor interests protected by law; as the reference concepts necessary for the definition of neighbor interest, "need" is proposed as a reflection of the internal characteristic of neighbor interest and "expectations" as an outward-oriented characteristic of neighbor interest. Conclusion . Traditional methods of protection, including a non-compete claim, do not always ensure the actual restoration of the violated interests of neighboring persons, which necessitates the development of more effective legal mechanisms, provided that there is a clear understanding of the legal nature of the object of such protection and defense.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Vinichenko et al. (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: