Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Although several writers express surprise that our findings for cancer seem inconsistent with earlier reports, these were mainly case–control studies, which are much more susceptible to bias than prospective studies ( 1 ) . Our null findings are largely consistent with more recent prospective studies, including the EPIC analysis of breast cancer ( 2 ) . We agree that our findings for fruit and vegetable intake do not exclude the possibility that specific compounds in these foods have anticancer properties. In fact, we have provided examples from these same cohorts to support such relationships with specific cancers ( 3 , 4 ) . However, if anticancer compounds vary dramatically in foods because of growing and harvesting conditions, degree of maturity, processing, storage, and cooking, then simply eating more fruits and vegetables would not be a reliable way to reduce overall cancer risk. It is this latter issue that our study addressed. Moreover, we have shown that blood levels of even fairly labile nutrients such as folic acid and beta-carotene are predicted by calculated intakes from our questionnaire ( 5 ), indicating that variability due to the above factors is not an intractable problem. This is in part because these sources of errors are dampened by the fact that individuals do not always eat exactly the same sample of food; thus, for example, the average nutrient content of carrots consumed by one person is probably not greatly different from the average nutrient content of carrots consumed by another. Our questionnaire did not have specific questions on how most fruits and vegetables were processed before eating. To examine the issue of raw versus cooked, we assumed that most fruits are consumed without processing and cooking, and hence we were unable to distinguish raw fruits from other fruits. We also identified raw vegetables for which we had information on processing or that were likely to be consumed without processing. These vegetables include coleslaw and uncooked cabbage, raw carrot, alfalfa sprouts, celery, raw spinach, iceberg and other head lettuce, and romaine and other leaf lettuce. The results ( Table 1 ) show that intakes of both the raw vegetable group and the remaining vegetables were not associated with risk of cancer. Hence, the reduction of these active vitamins and minerals due to processing is probably unlikely to explain the null association. Multivariable-adjusted relative risks * (with 95% confidence intervals) for major chronic disease, by intake of raw and other groups of vegetables Relative risks were adjusted for total calorie intake, age, smoking status, alcohol use, body mass index, multivitamin and vitamin E supplement use, physical activity, family history of myocardial infarction, family history of colon cancer, personal history of hypertension, personal history of hypercholesterolemia, personal history of diabetes, and, for women only, family history of breast cancer, menopausal status, and use of hormone replacement therapy. Relative risks are given relative to quintile 1, the lowest intake. HPFS = Health Professionals Follow-up Study; NHS = Nurses' Health Study. Raw vegetables include coleslaw and uncooked cabbage, raw carrot, alfalfa sprouts, celery, raw spinach, iceberg and other head lettuce, and romaine and other leaf lettuce. Other vegetables include the remaining vegetables that are not included in the list of raw vegetables; these could include vegetables that may be consumed raw or processed. Multivariable-adjusted relative risks * (with 95% confidence intervals) for major chronic disease, by intake of raw and other groups of vegetables Relative risks were adjusted for total calorie intake, age, smoking status, alcohol use, body mass index, multivitamin and vitamin E supplement use, physical activity, family history of myocardial infarction, family history of colon cancer, personal history of hypertension, personal history of hypercholesterolemia, personal history of diabetes, and, for women only, family history of breast cancer, menopausal status, and use of hormone replacement therapy. Relative risks are given relative to quintile 1, the lowest intake. HPFS = Health Professionals Follow-up Study; NHS = Nurses' Health Study. Raw vegetables include coleslaw and uncooked cabbage, raw carrot, alfalfa sprouts, celery, raw spinach, iceberg and other head lettuce, and romaine and other leaf lettuce. Other vegetables include the remaining vegetables that are not included in the list of raw vegetables; these could include vegetables that may be consumed raw or processed.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Hung et al. (2005) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: