Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Bibliometric research has developed increasingly explicit standards for study design, retrieval, reporting, reproducibility, indicator use, and interpretation. Yet procedural transparency does not by itself establish whether a bibliometric output warrants the substantive claim attached to it. This conceptual article introduces TRACE, a claim-centred architecture linking Theoretical Framing, Retrieval Sensitivity, Analytical Output, and Claim Calibration, with Epistemic Audit operating across the resulting stages and dependencies. ECART audits the same architecture in reverse. It first separates auditability from epistemic support, then completes the reverse traversal before identifying consequential problems and selecting a proportionate remedy. TRACE was developed through conceptual synthesis of adjacent methodological guidance rather than systematic review or validation. Four published cases illustrate different diagnoses at the output-to-claim and retrieval levels, while a reflexive audit constrains claims made for the framework itself. TRACE’s contribution is to connect claim-level diagnosis with proportionate revision decisions through an explicit audit procedure that complements existing methodological guidance. Its reliability, usability, diagnostic performance, and effects on authoring and review decisions remain to be empirically evaluated.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Greta Baldanzi (2026) studied this question.