Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
This study contrasted personal life narratives describing Action and Reaction oriented life episodes. Action episodes involve an attempt to achieve a goal or adjust to the demands of a situation with emotion resulting either from the fulfilment or frustration of these efforts. Reaction episodes involve holistic experiences with sensory, affective, and organic responses to autobiographically meaningful events. One hundred and fifty-one students at the University of Toronto completed a three-part questionnaire, each with 13 items, which was examined with factor analysis. The order in the questionnaire actually was - the first part inquired about Action, the second part Reaction, and the third part General responses to emotional episodes. In accordance with mainstream social psychological theorizing about emotion, intensity and attributional attention to causes loaded on separate factors for the Action model. An holistic response unifying the two factors was found for the Reaction model. Twenty-two of these respondents participated in an indepth interview recounting one Action and one Reaction episode. A content analysis was performed on the interview protocols and 10 categories were derived. Factor analysis on the frequency with which these categories were present in the individual protocols revealed contrasting motifs. Accounts of Action episodes reflected emotional detachment and responses to the actions of others. Reaction narratives reflected either an absorption in negative episodes or empathic responses on behalf of others. From an evolutionary perspective, the Action model lies on a autonomic fear-anger continuum involving both enhancement of neocortex planning along with the inhibition and transformation of potentially distracting emotions into generalized arousal. The Reaction model has a strong facial feedback component reflecting conditioned organic, perceptual, and cognitive responses to contextually complex events lying on the happiness-sadness dimension of social connection or loss.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Cupchik et al. (2005) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: