Key result
DWI-ASPECTS shows widely variable interrater agreement in acute anterior circulation stroke.
Why the study?
Although DWI-ASPECTS aids patient selection for thrombectomy in anterior circulation stroke, clinicians' interrater and intrarater agreement on the score needed systematic evaluation.
Systematic Review (n=2,472)
Clinician agreement on DWI-ASPECTS in anterior circulation acute ischemic stroke varies widely from poor to excellent depending on the statistical measure used, with a critical lack of reliability data for large core infarcts (DWI-ASPECTS <6).
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Variable DWI-ASPECTS agreement warrants caution for thrombectomy selection; challenges reliability assumptions and leaves open standardization needs.
Background The DWI-ASPECT score (DWI-ASPECTS) can aid patients’ selection for thrombectomy. This systematic review aimed to evaluate clinicians’ interrater and intrarater agreement on DWI-ASPECTS for anterior circulation stroke patients. Methods We conducted a broad search of electronic databases (CINAHL, EBM Reviews, MEDLINE, EMBASE & EMBASE Classic) between January 1st, 2000, and September 9 th , 2026. Our primary outcome was to collect data on any available measures of agreement for DWI-ASPECTS. Measures of agreement collected included ICC (intraclass correlation coefficient), weighted or unweighted kappa. Results Out of 3,658 articles screened, nineteen studies reporting 37 measures of agreement were included in the review. Populations, methods, analyses, and results were heterogeneous (poor to excellent agreement), precluding a meta-analysis. For interrater agreement, measures of agreement using full scale ICC ranged from strong to excellent, ranged from poor to strong using unweighted kappa, and ranged from moderate to excellent using weighted kappa. Only four studies offered interrater agreement values on DWI-ASPECTS<6. Only two studies offered information on intrarater agreement values. Conclusion Data on the reliability of DWI-ASPECTS in acute ischemic stroke is scant, while the methodologies and results in the studies assessed are heterogeneous. More robust studies are required, particularly for strokes with DWI-ASPECTS <6.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Jamal et al. (2026) conducted a systematic review in Acute ischemic stroke of the anterior circulation (n=2,472). DWI-ASPECTS (Diffusion-Weighted Imaging Alberta Stroke Program Early CT Score) assessment vs. Interrater and intrarater scoring comparisons across clinicians was evaluated on Interrater and intrarater agreement on DWI-ASPECTS (measured by intraclass correlation coefficient [ICC], unweighted kappa, and weighted kappa). DWI-ASPECTS interrater agreement in anterior circulation stroke varied widely across 19 studies, with ICCs of 0.72-0.96, weighted kappas of 0.441-0.985, and unweighted kappas of 0.17-0.76.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: