Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
This paper does not answer the question "who am I"; it reformulates the question as: under what conditions may a dharma legitimately be called "self" (wo/ātman)? Drawing on four corpora — the Qianlong Canon in full (1,778 titles, c. 60.3 million characters), CBETA for sectional verification, the Pali SuttaCentral and CSCD (Sixth Council) editions, and Sanskrit/Tibetan materials from Derge and the GRETIL-collated MPS fragments — the argument proceeds in four steps. (1) Terminological clearing: searching definitional formulae rather than word frequency shows that "true self" (zhenwo) occurs zero times as a technical term in the Āgamas and is a Chinese construction of the Mahāparinirvāṇa-sūtra tradition, while the Āgamic definition of self by "mastery" is structurally identical with "self-mastery" (aiśvarya) among the six qualities of the tathāgatagarbha; absence of the word is therefore not absence of the meaning. (2) A criterial definition: the six qualities are treated as a conjunction of necessary conditions, yielding "if a dharma satisfies the six, it is the true self", qualified fourfold (non-substantial, non-singular, attained at fruition, predicated of nirvāṇa rather than of a person). (3) Layering: self admits a nature layer (seeing-nature as a property, common and indifferent to unity or plurality, grounding the non-perishing of a type rather than of an individual), a phenomenal layer (the five aggregates, necessarily perishable), and a structural layer (the locus whose nature is precisely that seeing, non-objectifiable, distributive, non-substitutable). The third layer is derived by elimination and cannot be reduced to the first two. (4) A threshold for "implicit scriptural warrant", with three tests, applied to the grammatical status of "mind" in the Awakening of Faith and to the hermeneutic rule "remove the disease, not the dharma". Evidence is graded in four levels throughout; three cases of homonymy are registered rather than silently resolved; one earlier position is formally retracted. The conclusion claims only the best available explanation, not final truth, and states three open questions with their falsification conditions.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Jingwen Feng (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 8 closely related papers on similar clinical questions. Consider them for comparative context: