Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Precipitation data are essential for exploring climate variability, eco-hydrological modeling, agricultural planning and drought and flood monitoring, and water-resource management. However, sparse and unevenly distributed rain-gauge networks limit the availability of reliable rainfall observations in the Upper Blue Nile Basin. This study evaluates the performance of six widely used satellite and reanalysis precipitation products CHIRPS v2.0 (CHIRPS), IMERG v6.0 (IMERG), TAMSAT v3.1 (TAMSAT), MSWEP v2.8 (MSWEP), PERSIANN-CDR, and ERA5, against gauge observations from seven meteorological stations in the Guder sub-basin during 2001–2015. Performance was assessed at daily, monthly, and seasonal scales using categorical indices (POD, FAR, FBI, CSI), continuous statistics (Bias, R, RMSE, KGE), and ETCCDI-based extreme precipitation indices. For precipitation occurrence, MSWEP and IMERG showed superior detection skill, with higher POD and CSI and lower FAR, whereas ERA5 consistently performed worst. For precipitation totals, clear scale dependency was evident. MSWEP performed best at the daily scale (R = 0.73, KGE = 0.71, RMSE = 3.29 mm), followed by TAMSAT and IMERG. At the monthly scale, performance improved for all products, with CHIRPS and IMERG emerging as the most reliable datasets, both achieving correlations above 0.97 and strong KGE values. Seasonally, CHIRPS and MSWEP performed better during the small rainy (February–March) and dry (October–January) seasons, while all products showed reduced skill during the main rainy season (June–September) due to intense monsoonal variability. For precipitation extremes, no single dataset consistently outperformed others. MSWEP showed balanced performance for wet/dry spell indices and moderate rainfall, CHIRPS performed better for annual totals and moderate extremes, IMERG captured heavy and very heavy rainfall events (R95p, R20mm) more effectively, and PERSIANN-CDR performed relatively better in rainfall intensity (SDII). ERA5 remained the weakest across most extreme indices. CHIRPS, MSWEP, and IMERG were identified as the most reliable precipitation datasets for hydrological and climate-related applications in the Guder Sub-basin.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Gezahegn et al. (2026) studied this question.