Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Papers that attribute a large earthquake to static stress transfer from an earlier one usually compute the Coulomb stress change with a single finite fault model of the earlier event. The uncertainty of that sign has been measured within single inversions, but not between independent published models across many earthquakes. We ask how often the sign at the hypocenter of a later large earthquake changes with the choice of model, and whether later large earthquakes sit in stress increases more often than earlier earthquakes in the same area. The study was preregistered before any stress was computed. We used the 86 earthquakes of Mw 7.5 and above from 2010 to 2026. For each, we resolved the stress change of the USGS finite fault model onto both nodal planes of every event of magnitude 6.5 and above within 300 km in the five years after the mainshock. Such events in the five years before it serve as the control. The share of positive changes was 0.54 after and 0.51 before the mainshocks (difference +0.03, 95 percent interval -0.20 to +0.25, 59 mainshocks), so the two cannot be separated with this sample. On 13 mainshocks with independent published models, 51 later events had a sign that agreed on both nodal planes under the USGS model. Replacing that model with another published one gave the opposite sign in 0.20 of the comparisons on average (interval 0.08 to 0.25), and 0.53 of these events changed sign under at least one model. A static triggering sign computed from one finite fault model near the rupture therefore carries a model dependence that should be reported with it. Version 1. The code and data package reproduces every number in the preprint; see README.md inside the archive. Second models of other authors are downloaded by fetchsecond.py and are not redistributed.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Wenjie Lyu (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 8 closely related papers on similar clinical questions. Consider them for comparative context: