Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
What is the Gadgil effect? In field and laboratory experiments in New Zealand, Gadgil & Gadgil (1971, 1975) found that when ectomycorrhizal roots were excluded from Pinus radiata litter, the rate of litter decomposition increased dramatically over a 12-month period. This 'Gadgil effect' was attributed to stimulated colonization and exploitation of litter by ectomycorrhizal fungi at the expense of litter decomposing saprotrophs, and was used to explain the accumulation of the slowly degraded organic 'mor' humus horizons which characteristically form in forests of ectomycorrhizal tree species. However, attempts to corroborate the 'Gadgil effect' in subsequent studies have met with a variety of results, and the area has become a contentious area of soil microbiology. The study of Koide & Wu reported in this issue (pp. 401–407) provides a simple additional explanation for the 'Gadgil effect' and goes some way to account for inconsistencies in the literature dealing with this subject. The simplest explanation for the 'Gadgil effect' has been the direct inhibition of saprotrophic organisms by ectomycorrhizal fungi. Although some ectomycorrhizal fungi have the capacity to break down organic components of litter these are small relative to saprotrophic fungi (Colpaert & van Tichelen, 1996). Exploitation of litter resources by ectomycorrhizal fungi in preference to saprotrophic fungi would therefore result in reduced rates of litter decomposition. Some ectomycorrhizal fungi have indeed been shown to outcompete saprotrophic fungi for territory (Lindahl et al., 2001), although the outcome of interactions between these fungal groups appears to depend on species and carbon availability to each of the combatants. Ectomycorrhizal mycelium can also cause substantial inhibition of the activities of soil bacteria, although again, the size of the effect varies between different species of ectomycorrhizal fungus (Olsson et al., 1996). The production of antibiotic compounds by ectomycorrhizal fungi, particularly organic acids, has been implicated in the direct inhibition of saprotrophic organisms by ectomycorrhizal mycelium (Rasanayagam & Jeffries, 1992). Direct competition between ectomycorrhizal fungi and saprotrophs for nitrogen has also been implicated in the 'Gadgil effect'. Nitrogen availability is a key factor determining rates of cellulose degradation by saprotrophic organisms (Park, 1976). Abuzinadah et al. (1986) suggested that the selective exploitation and translocation of N from litter to the host plant could result in N limitation to saprotrophic organisms, leading to reduced rates of litter decomposition. Further studies have clearly demonstrated that colonization of litter by ectomycorrhizal fungi reduces the quality of litter remaining, by increasing the C : N ratio, and depleting N, P and K contents (Bending & Read, 1995). The magnitude of the 'Gadgil effect' could therefore be expected to depend on the availability of N and other nutrients in the particular soil being studied. Koide & Wu have provided an alternative explanation for the 'Gadgil effect'. Litter decomposition, ectomycorrhiza density and moisture content were followed over a 12-month period in a Pinus resinosa plantation. It was found that litter decomposition was reduced as ectomycorrhiza density increased, confirming the findings of Gadgil & Gadgil (1971, 1975). Significantly, it was shown that litter moisture content was also reduced as ectomycorrhiza density increased. Moisture content is a key determinant of forest litter decomposition, affecting the size, composition and activities of saprotrophic communities (Robinson, 2002). The drying induced by ectomycorrhizal roots in the study of Koide & Wu was of the order of magnitude known to be sufficient to cause substantial reduction in litter decomposition rates. Similar evidence for changes in litter moisture content following colonization by ectomycorrhizal roots and mycelium have been reported in many studies (Griffiths et al., 1990; Parmalee et al., 1993; Zhu & Ehrenfeld, 1996). The possibility that water removal contributes to the 'Gadgil effect' would provide some explanation for discrepancies in the literature dealing with this subject. The significance of changes to soil moisture content would depend on the prevailing weather conditions, and would therefore vary according to season and between years. In dry weather, when water could become a factor limiting the growth and activities of saprotrophic organisms, the uptake and translocation of water by ectomycorrhizal roots could result in the inhibition of saprotrophic organisms, reducing litter decomposition. During wet weather, changes to litter moisture content caused by ectomycorrhizal roots may have little effect on saprotrophic organisms. However, it is likely that any ectomycorrhizal root induced changes to litter moisture content would need to be maintained over a prolonged period to have long-term impacts on decomposition (O'Neil et al., 2003). Ectomycorrhiza induced change to soil moisture content is evidently only one of several factors which may interact to control the impacts of ectomycorrhizal roots on litter decomposition rates. Zhu & Ehrenfeld (1996) found stimulated decomposition of litter following colonization by ectomycorrhizal roots in the mineral soil of a Pinus resinosa plantation, despite consistently lower moisture contents in ectomycorrhiza colonized litter relative to uncolonized litter. Parmalee et al. (1993) showed that in organic forest soil horizons moisture content, microbial biomass, microbial growth rate and extractable N declined with increasing root density, although the sizes of faunal groups were not affected. However in the soil's mineral horizon, increasing root density stimulated microbial growth and faunal communities. Similarly, Priha et al. (1999) showed that the presence of ectomycorrhizal roots reduced rates of soil respiration in the organic horizon of a mor forest soil, but stimulated decomposition in the underlying mineral horizon. The suppression of litter decomposition induced by mycorrhizal roots thus appears to be limited to organic soil horizons which have low N availability and are probably more susceptible to fluctuations in moisture content. In mineral soils the presence of ectomycorrhizal roots evidently stimulates the activities of carbon-limited saprotrophic organisms following the rhizodeposition of labile carbon. These interactions must be further complicated by the considerable functional diversity that exists between different species of ectomycorrhizal fungus with respect to water uptake and translocation, nitrogen mobilization and translocation, and antagonistic interactions.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Gary D. Bending (2003) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: