Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Bedrock river incision models rely on an erodibility coefficient, K, that aggregates lithology, climate, sediment supply, and channel hydraulics into a single term, yet is typically the least constrained parameter in the stream power incision model and its derivatives. This paper has two aims: to give researchers practical guidance on how to estimate and report K, and to demonstrate quantitatively why residual uncertainty in K matters for the landscape evolution models using it. First, we systematically review 25 studies that estimate bedrock erodibility using geomorphic, geochemical and geophysical, or model-calibration and inverse methods. From this review we synthesise a decision framework that directs a prospective user to a method suited to their scientific objective and available data, five cross-cutting caveats that must be considered regardless of method, and four reporting practices that would improve the comparability and reusability of K estimates. Second, we propagate a tightly constrained, single-lithology erodibility range through detachment-limited and sediment-coupled landscape evolution simulations of a real catchment, to test how much this residual uncertainty changes model predictions. Even within a short modelled timeframe in which no configuration approaches long-term equilibrium, this range produces a real, monotonic, and in places mass-conserved divergence in predicted erosion rate, slope, and eroded volume. Switching model formulation at fixed erodibility shifts the predicted response systematically and in a direction that was not anticipated in advance: the sediment-coupled model erodes less than the detachment-limited model, via transient sediment shielding of the bed. Together, these results give researchers both a practical framework for choosing and reporting an erodibility estimate, and quantitative evidence that the method, exponent convention, and model formulation behind that estimate cannot be separated from the value itself.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Piyathilake et al. (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 8 closely related papers on similar clinical questions. Consider them for comparative context: