Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Within the discourse of sustainable development, which often remains confined to ecological and economic dimensions, culture-based social sustainability in local traditions functioning as mechanisms of social cohesion has rarely been critically examined. This study examined the explanatory capacity and limitations of Dempsey's social sustainability framework through the practice of bethek-sinoman in the Entas-entas ceremony of the Tengger community, arguing that social sustainability in this tradition cannot be fully explained by structural indicators alone. The research was conducted in Tosari and Ngadiwono Villages, Tosari District, Pasuruan Regency, using a qualitative ethnographic approach to capture the meaning of bethek-sinoman as experienced directly by its practitioners. The findings show that Dempsey's framework effectively maps several surface dimensions of social sustainability, including equitable access across economic, educational, and religious boundaries; community sustainability, reflected in successive stages that renew communal bonds well before the ritual's culmination; both physical and non-physical resource contributions; and social inclusion, evident in collective participation involving thousands of people. However, the framework fails to account for practices such as Tengger women's willingness to bear heavier workloads based on belief in an inherited ancestral trait, or residents' voluntary restraint from technology use as an expression of personal shame and dignity, phenomena that cannot be reduced to measurable role distribution or social network indicators. These findings indicate that the social sustainability of bethek-sinoman rests on both an equitable, inclusive system and residents' spiritual-emotional attachment to ancestors and kin, which renders norms internalized rather than externally imposed. The study concludes that understanding the social sustainability of indigenous communities requires combining universal theoretical frameworks as structural maps with ethnographic approaches that explore meanings exceeding those maps' boundaries.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Nisa et al. (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: