Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Electric-vehicle battery packs are commonly retired from vehicle service at 70-80% state of health, and it is often assumed that most of them can move directly into stationary storage. This paper models that transition for a stated 60 kWh reference pack and derives the condition under which pack-level reuse, without opening the pack for cell- or module-level rework, is worthwhile. Derating the pack to 0.25C and 60% depth of discharge reduces the cycling fade rate from 0.01333 to 0.00301 state-of-health points per equivalent full cycle, but calendar fade at 1.0 point per year then becomes the binding limit: a pack retired at 75% state of health delivers 8.56 years of stationary service to a 60% end-of-life threshold, not the 19.93 years the cycle budget alone would allow, and 57.1% of its cycle throughput is never delivered. The screening bound is set by the weakest of 16 series modules: pack-level reuse pays only if module capacity dispersion stays below a coefficient of variation of 2.85% and the highest module resistance stays below 1.5 times the median. Applied to a stated population of 1,000 retired packs, 81.3% fail at least one screen and only 18.7% qualify for direct pack-level reuse. The honest headline is negative for the common assumption: direct reuse is a minority route, and screening, not installation, is where the second-life industry will spend its effort. All results are SIMULATED, NOT MEASURED.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
William Alexander Aldred (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 8 closely related papers on similar clinical questions. Consider them for comparative context: