Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
A vertical stick casts a noon shadow whose length follows the Sun's declination, and communities have long used the shortest noon shadow of the year to mark the summer solstice. This paper computes, from stated assumptions, how precisely that method can date the solstice, and how the precision depends on stick height and latitude. The solar declination is modelled with the standard Cooper approximation (axial tilt 23.44 degrees), the noon shadow of a stick of height h at latitude phi is h multiplied by the absolute value of tan(phi minus delta), and the shadow tip is assumed readable to plus or minus 2 mm. Because the shadow reaches an extreme value at the solstice, its length departs from that extreme only quadratically in the number of days from the solstice: during the first day after the solstice the shadow of a 1 m stick changes by only 0.061 to 0.083 mm across latitudes 0 to 55 degrees. The resulting dating uncertainty for a 1 m stick is 4.89 to 5.74 days, and for a hand-length stick of 0.30 m it is 8.94 to 10.48 days, so a hand-length stick cannot date the solstice within a week at any of the latitudes computed. Dating the solstice to within plus or minus 2 days requires a stick 5.99 to 8.24 m tall, depending on latitude. At the equinox, by contrast, the noon shadow moves almost linearly at 7.04 to 21.52 mm per day per metre of stick, and the same 0.30 m stick dates the equinox to within 0.31 to 0.95 days. The solstice is therefore a poor date to fix by shadow length alone, while the equinox is a good one, and any tradition that needs an accurate solstice date from shadows must either use a structure several metres tall or count days from a nearby equinox instead. This study is simulated, not measured.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
William Alexander Aldred (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 8 closely related papers on similar clinical questions. Consider them for comparative context: