Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Global preservation does not determine what a finite observer can recover. Observer-Dependent En-tropy Retrieval (ODER) makes the passage from preserved encoding to retained possession calculable through causal collection, joint access, and receiving dynamics. For finite Hayden–Preskill sources cou-pled to Schwarzschild propagation and a causal detector, we hold the source, late-radiation apparatus, and collection lifetime fixed. Across all 32 source states, optimal deterministic entanglement-recovery fidelity is at most 0.3308 without early radiation and at least 0.8476 with it. The upper bound applies to every decoder on the available registers, even when decoding computation is unrestricted. A controlled catcher carries this separation into memory; a separate two-site receiver retains a certified separation with finite switching and lossy storage. Independent identical zero-mean Gaussian rail noise admits an exact Pauli–erasure reduction at a specified coherent one-photon interface, yielding deterministic recovery certificates. A separate effective outgoing-field model shows how observer ordering depends on the matched time, incident stream, and receiver controls. Matched spectral trans-mission and mean delay leave finite-window access undetermined. A finite tensor-network (MERA) comparison likewise finds different reference information at identical collection size and individual inclusion probabilities. Removing disentanglers increases mean acquisition under both protocols while reducing their mean difference. Sharp access envelopes and an exact calibration-sufficiency criterion identify the missing information; an additional joint-collection statistic supplies a uniform recovery guarantee. In a five-carrier code, independently erasing collected shares reverses the ranking of two access protocols whose individual efficiencies remain matched. A reference-assisted verification construction shows that preserved encoding and reference erasure induce identical channels below its joint-access threshold and become distinguishable with sufficient access. Once collected, the diary correlations must enter memory and remain there. Uniform capture of an arbitrary collected register gives an exact conditional-mutual-information transfer law in the presence of early side information. Recorded progressive collection extends that channel to randomly admitted registers, with exact infor-mation dynamics and a finite-memory deadline certificate. A centered modular preparation attains the sharp strip-holomorphic activation envelope, and a finite receiver approximates its trajectory with explicit resource requirements. Programmable receiver tests and a staged BEC program connect these constructions to controlled measurements. The resulting standard is physical: the stated data must suffice to establish the claimed recovery or verification performance. The channel constructions determine when that standard is met and which additional measurement can settle an otherwise undetermined claim.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
E.H. Cooper (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 8 closely related papers on similar clinical questions. Consider them for comparative context: