Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Finite directed acyclic graphs can carry both a Boolean causal relation and matrix-valued coherent path transport. These objects need not admit the same coarse description. We compare two separately stipulated instruments: a nilpotent retarded path response and a positive, connection-based quadratic comparison form. For a unit-weight two-path diamond with unitary total path maps P, Q, exact interior elimination produces a normalized coarse map K = (P + Q)/2 together with a forced nonnegative source-endpoint term V = I − K†K. Relative path holonomy determines the singular spectrum of K and the eigenvalues of V. Destructive interference can erase the complex response without erasing Boolean reachability, and total intensity need not identify the effective boundary spectrum. The exact spectral Schur complement additionally retains frequency dependence: its static zero-frequency reduction does not generally reproduce the retained block of a postulated unitary dynamics. A separate orientation-blindness proposition shows that even the entire frequency-dependent comparison response cannot determine directed reachability. Weighted disjoint-path formulas and explicit overlapping-path counterexamples isolate information lost by naive reductions. The connection-conductance and series/parallel identities have close published precedents, especially Cloninger and collaborators (2024); our focus is the exact distinction between a directed path-sum instrument and orientation-insensitive connection-energy instruments. Most finite-dimensional statements are machine-checked in Lean 4; Section 9 records the exact coverage. Their synthesis is a candidate mathematical research note, not evidence for a microscopic physical law, particles, quantum fields, or a unique spacetime ontology.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Cecil Jentges (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 8 closely related papers on similar clinical questions. Consider them for comparative context: