Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
During a recent conversation, a colleague described a derogatory remark made to her by a health professional. The remark, which was made in an official capacity, questioned, perhaps even refuted, one of the most basic human rights for people diagnosed with a mental illness. I would like to relay the entire comment but cannot at the risk of breaching confidentiality. My first response to the statement was one of indignation and anger. With the benefit of time to reflect, my reaction became more one of concern and disappointment, that despite the rhetoric and a plethora of impressive policy documents, we sometimes appear to have made so little gain in reducing the stigma of, and discrimination against, people experiencing a mental illness. While one example should probably not spark so strong a reaction, I am sure we are all aware that this is not an isolated example. In February this year, the Melbourne media came alive in response to a leaked letter from the medical director of a major Melbourne hospital. In essence, the letter suggested that a crisis in the availability of mental health beds had resulted in large numbers of mental health service users disrupting the smooth operation of the general health care system. Emergency departments in particular, were described as ‘holding bays’ for ‘a flood of psychiatric patients’. Mental health consumers were portrayed as disturbed and aggressive, with a strong underlying assumption that they were accessing services at the expense of others more deserving, namely, the physically ill and injured. Few mental health nurses would be likely to dispute the underlying philosophy of mainstreaming. I am confident we would all agree that access to the highest standard of health care services should be a fundamental human right, irrespective of the nature of the health care issue that has led to seeking care and treatment. The above examples clearly highlight the fact that changing policy is a considerably more straightforward process than changing attitudes. While such discriminatory and marginalizing attitudes continue to exist, there is no possibility that consumers of mental health services will be receiving an optimal standard of care. So what can we as mental health nurses do about it? It is of course very easy to become despondent and frustrated at what frequently appears to be an insurmountable problem. However, as mental health professionals we need to move beyond our individual reactions and recognize our role as advocates, not only for the profession of mental health nursing but most importantly for the consumers of mental health services. Mental health nurses must continually challenge the discriminatory attitudes of general health professionals and either subtly or overtly influence them towards the development of more open and inclusive attitudes. Whether employed within health care, government or academia, mental health nurses can be influential. Yes it can be frustrating, sometimes soul destroying, to repeatedly have to remind others to consider the fundamental human rights of people who are equally deserving of respect and dignity, and yes it is easy to feel hostility towards our colleagues in the general health care system who just don’t seem to get it, but frankly we have no choice. By chipping away at the iceberg we can make our contribution to improving the attitudes towards, and the quality of services for, the consumers of mental health services.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Brenda Happell (2005) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: