Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Knowing not only quantities but also pathways of water through a catchment is crucial for an in‐depth understanding of hydrological processes and the pathways of contaminants in the environment. We present a combined approach to validate the horizontal and vertical water transfer through a distributed hydrological model using a fully independent geochemical mixing model and applied it to the mesoscale (42 km 2 ) Claduègne catchment under Mediterranean climate. We aimed to cross‐validate streamflow contributions simulated by the two models over a large range of hydrological conditions, including high frequency over flood events. The catchment comprises two contrasting lithologies and mixed land uses, including extensive, diversified agriculture, towns and forests. The model (J2000P) is distributed over hydrologic response units and includes a detailed representation of human activity. It was calibrated on discharge at three hydrometric stations throughout the catchment. A geochemical mixing model was developed in parallel, with six end‐members as combinations of lithology, land cover and flow processes. Simulated stream flow contributions were compared to the hydrological model for an independent evaluation. Both models showed overland flow (OF) contributions that reached up to 80%–90% during intense flood events. The models generally agreed on intra‐ and inter‐event patterns of contributions of OF, urban sources and lithology as well as the relation of these contributions to discharge regime. The best agreements were obtained during the autumn flood season, while some disagreements were identified under dry conditions and in summer, during which the hydrological response to precipitation is more complex. Comparing streamflow contributions from two independent models validates whether the right discharge results are obtained for the right reasons (flow‐generating processes and spatial origins). Furthermore, this comparison extends validation of the hydrological model beyond total discharge to include an explicit validation of where the water comes from.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Hachgenei et al. (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: