Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Before probabilities, Hilbert spaces or linear structure are introduced, procedures already compose: some are idempotent, some can be repeated indefinitely, and symmetries permute them. We ask which systems can carry a minimal structure of this kind faithfully: a monoid with a non-vanishing additive grading, a commutative idempotent zero-grade sector and a symmetry group that fixes a reference state and acts faithfully and non-Abelianly on the joinirreducible elements of that sector. Such a monoid needs at least four generators, and ℕ0 × B3 attains the bound. For any convex state space, the reachable region must have affine dimension at least four. A classical system therefore needs five perfectly distinguishable states, and five suffice. A qubit is excluded by dimension, and more strongly because its non-trivial idempotent channels are dephasings along diameters, and a qutrit because the fixed sets of its idempotent channels cannot intersect in the required pattern; among all systems with at most four perfectly distinguishable states, classical, quantum or hybrid, only the four-level quantum system carries it. Two qubits suffice: the Pauli dephasings along X1, Z1 and Y1Z2 generate B3, global depolarization supplies the grading, and a six-element Clifford group permutes the dephasings as the full S3 while fixing a full-rank state on which the monoid acts injectively. On a superconducting processor the predicted Pauli eigenvalues are reproduced within 0.009, and on two devices the entangling symmetry fixes the reference state within 0.045 and permutes the dephasings as S3.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Alexander M. Tishin (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 8 closely related papers on similar clinical questions. Consider them for comparative context: