Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Interactive medical diagnosis requires sequential symptom elicitation before a diagnosis can be established. Although recent approaches employ reinforcement learning and transformer-based agents, their performance has not been adequately contextualized against a classical probabilistic baseline. This study introduces a training-free symbolic baseline that derives conditional symptom probabilities and three rule slots—must-have, exclusion, and critical—from co-occurrence counts in simulated patient records. Candidate diseases are ranked using observed evidence, while subsequent questions are selected by expected information gain. Evaluation on five benchmarks from a published reinforcement learning study reveals distinct performance regimes. On MedlinePlus (893 diseases), the proposed method achieves 99.27 ± 0.09% accuracy with an average of 1.75 questions, outperforming the published baseline (96.2 ± 0.1%; 3.41 questions). Across four SymCat variants, it improves accuracy by 3.03–7.70 percentage points but requires approximately twice as many questions; at a matched budget of 8.98 questions, the reference method achieves higher accuracy, highlighting a trade-off between diagnostic accuracy and interaction cost. Ablation experiments across six datasets show that removing weighted evidence combination reduces accuracy by 35.4–65.4 percentage points, while eliminating symptom inquiry reduces it by 23.3–66.8 percentage points. The safety veto removes up to 50.2% of candidates on average but changes the final diagnosis in at most 0.17% of consultations, indicating limited incremental impact on predictive accuracy under the evaluated configurations. Rule-base derivation takes 1.8 s for 893 diseases on a CPU. As all benchmarks rely on simulated patients, these findings establish benchmark-level performance rather than clinical effectiveness.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Nugraha et al. (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: